Abstract:Abstract Background The fraction of intercepted photosynthetically active radiation (fPARi) is typically described with a non-linear function of leaf area index (LAI) and k , the light extinction coefficient. The parameter k is used to make statistical inference, as an input into crop models, and for phenotyping. It may be estimated using a variety of statistical techniques that differ in assumptions, which ultimately influences the numerical value k and associated uncertainty estimates. A systematic search of peer-reviewed publications for maize ( Zea Mays L.) revealed: (i) incompleteness in reported estimation techniques; and (ii) that most studies relied on dated techniques with unrealistic assumptions, such as log-transformed linear models (LogTLM) or normally distributed data. These findings suggest that knowledge of the variety and trade-offs among statistical estimation techniques is lacking, which hinders the use of modern approaches such as Bayesian estimation (BE) and techniques with appropriate assumptions, e.g. assuming beta-distributed data. Results The parameter k was estimated for seven maize genotypes with five different methods: least squares estimation (LSE), LogTLM, maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) assuming normal distribution, MLE assuming beta distribution, and BE assuming beta distribution. Methods were compared according to the appropriateness for statistical inference, point estimates’ properties, and predictive performance. LogTLM produced the worst predictions for fPARi, whereas both LSE and MLE with normal distribution yielded unrealistic predictions (i.e. fPARi 1) and the greatest coefficients for k . Models with beta-distributed fPARi (either MLE or Bayesian) were recommended to obtain point estimates. Conclusion Each estimation technique has underlying assumptions which may yield different estimates of k and change inference, like the magnitude and rankings among genotypes. Thus, for reproducibility, researchers must fully report the statistical model, assumptions, and estimation technique. LogTLMs are most frequently implemented, but should be avoided to estimate k . Modeling fPARi with a beta distribution was an absent practice in the literature but is recommended, applying either MLE or BE. This workflow and technique comparison can be applied to other plant canopy models, such as the vertical distribution of nitrogen, carbohydrates, photosynthesis, etc. Users should select the method balancing benefits and tradeoffs matching the purpose of the study.

Extinction coefficients for radiation in plant canopies calculated using an ellipsoidal inclination angle distribution

Use of Debye’s Series to Determine the Optimal Edge-Effect Terms for Computing the Extinction Efficiencies of Spheroids

High-frequency Extinction Efficiencies of Spheroids: Rigorous T-matrix Solutions and Semi-Empirical Approximations

Edge-effect Contribution to the Extinction of Light by Dielectric Disks and Cylindrical Particles

[Simulation of leaf inclination angle distribution of main tree species in Daxing'an Mountains of China based on the Campbell ellipsoid distribution function]

A New Directional Canopy Emissivity Model Based on Spectral Invariants

Evaluation and Refinement of the Beer-Lambert Extinction Law in the Discontinuous Vegetation Canopy

Theoretical Estimation of Extinction Coefficient Due to Time Evolution of Particle Size Distribution

The impact of modifying photosystem antenna size on canopy photosynthetic efficiency-Development of a new canopy photosynthesis model scaling from metabolism to canopy level processes

Studies on the Role of Light Transmissibility of Single Leaf and Plant Type as Factors Constituting Light Extinction Coefficient K in Corn Plant Populations

A computational model for irradiance on close-in planetary systems

Insights Into Plant Size-Density Relationships From Models And Agricultural Crops

A practical guide to estimating the light extinction coefficient with nonlinear models—a case study on maize

Extinction coefficients from aerosol measurements

A universal model for carbon dioxide uptake by plants

Modeling Photosynthesis of Discontinuous Plant Canopies by Linking the Geometric Optical Radiative Transfer Model with Biochemical Processes

Quantifying Water-Use Efficiency in Plant Canopies with Varying Leaf Angle and Density Distribution

Importance of the description of light interception in crop growth models

Improving the Estimation of Canopy Fluorescence Escape Probability in the Near-Infrared Band by Accounting for Soil Reflectance

A New Canopy Emissivity Model for Sparsely Vegetated Surfaces Incorporating Soil Directional Emissivity and Topography

Calculating Canopy Stomatal Conductance from Eddy Covariance Measurements, in Light of the Energy Budget Closure Problem