Abstract:This study examines the ecological reliability, convergent validity and ecological stability of neighbourhood (dis)organizational processes measured by means of two methods: inhabitant surveys and the so-called key informant analysis technique. Considering that ecological processes play a major role in many contemporary criminological theories and research, it is vital to take into account methodological challenges and to question the reliability, validity and stability of the measures reflecting these underlying processes. (Dis)organizational processes are predominantly measured by means of questionnaires surveying neighbourhood inhabitants. To yield ecologically reliable and valid measures this approach requires large numbers of respondents. In this study we analyse the relationships between ecological measures of neighbourhood processes based on surveys of inhabitants versus key informants. The findings suggest that key informants can provide reliable, valid and stable measures of (dis)organizational neighbourhood processes. Therefore, the key informant analysis technique is an essential complementary, or even substitutive, method in the measurement of neighbourhood processes; shared survey-method variance is eliminated and it is possible to survey fewer key informants than inhabitants to obtain reliable and valid information on social trust and disorder. Nevertheless, this method is not suitable for measuring all neighbourhood processes, such as informal social control. Therefore, outstanding challenges and avenues for future research are discussed as well.

New Directions in Social Disorganization Theory

Disorder or Disadvantage: Investigating the Tension Between Neighborhood Social Structure and the Physical Environment on Local Violence

Testing Ecological Theories of Offender Spatial Decision Making Using a Discrete Choice Model

Small Communities in Crisis: Examining the Impact of Disaster on Crimes Using Social Disorganization Theory

Broken Windows and Community Social Control: Evidence from a Study of Street Segments

Broken Windows or Window Breakers: The Influence of Physical and Social Disorder on Quality of Life

Zoning Practices and Neighborhood Physical Disorder

Disorder, social capital, and norm violation: Three field experiments on the broken windows thesis

Collective Efficacy, Group Threat, and Urban Change: Examining Informal Social Control Forces in Areas of Gentrification

Structural neighbourhood characteristics, perceived collective efficacy and perceived disorder: a multilevel study on fear of crime

New Developments in Social Network Analysis

Neighbourhood places, collective efficacy and crime: A longitudinal perspective

Social Network Analysis of Crime Organization Structures

Looking Through Broken Windows: The Impact of Neighborhood Disorder on Aggression and Fear of Crime Is an Artifact of Research Design

Social Ties, Collective Efficacy, and Crime-Specific Fear in Seattle Neighborhoods

Urban Crime and Social Disorganization in China

Does Street Social Activity Impact Crime? An Analysis in New York City

The Criminological Significance of Social Network Analysis

Collective efficacy and disorder through the eyes of neighbourhood inhabitants and key informants

The Utility of Social Capital and Collective Efficacy: Social Control Policy in Nonmetropolitan Settings

The view from a broken window: How residents make sense of neighbourhood disorder in Flint