Abstract:Research Summary Broken windows theory suggests that police can prevent serious crime by addressing social and physical disorder in neighborhoods. In many U.S. cities, recent increases in disorder, fear, and crime have initiated calls for an intensification of disorder policing efforts. Disorder policing programs can be controversial, with evaluations yielding conflicting results. Further, a growing number of descriptive analyses of aggressive order maintenance programs raise concerns over varied negative consequences, such as increased racial disparities in arrests of citizens. Systematic review and meta‐analytic techniques were used to conduct an updated analysis of the effects of disorder policing on crime. Fifty‐six eligible studies including 59 independent tests of disorder policing interventions were identified, representing almost twice the number included in the previous review. As part of the meta‐analysis, new effect size metrics were used. The updated meta‐analysis suggests that policing disorder strategies are associated with overall statistically significant crime reduction effects that spill over into surrounding areas. The strongest program effect sizes were generated by community and problem‐solving interventions designed to change social and physical disorder conditions at crime hot spots. Conversely, aggressive order maintenance strategies did not generate significant crime reductions. Policy Implications The types of strategies used by police departments to address disorder seem to matter in controlling crime, and this holds important implications for police–community relations, justice, and crime prevention. Further research is needed to understand the key programmatic elements that maximize the capacity of these strategies to prevent crime.

Zoning Practices and Neighborhood Physical Disorder

Disorder policing to reduce crime: An updated systematic review and meta‐analysis

Broken Windows or Window Breakers: The Influence of Physical and Social Disorder on Quality of Life

Disorder or Disadvantage: Investigating the Tension Between Neighborhood Social Structure and the Physical Environment on Local Violence

Disorder affects judgements about a neighbourhood: police presence does not

The view from a broken window: How residents make sense of neighbourhood disorder in Flint

Ecological assessments of community disorder: their relationship to fear of crime and theoretical implications

Social and environmental determinants of physical activity in urban parks: Testing a neighborhood disorder model

Looking Through Broken Windows: The Impact of Neighborhood Disorder on Aggression and Fear of Crime Is an Artifact of Research Design

Neighborhood Connections, Physical Disorder, and Neighborhood Satisfaction in Las Vegas

Neighborhood social conditions mediate the association between physical deterioration and mental health

Contextualizing from Within: Perceptions of Physical Disorder in a South Central L.A. African American Mosque

The Effects of Multilayered Disorder Characteristics on Fear of Crime in Korea

Disorder, social capital, and norm violation: Three field experiments on the broken windows thesis

Factors affecting crime, fear of crime and satisfaction with police: focusing on policing and the neighborhood context

Broken Windows and Community Social Control: Evidence from a Study of Street Segments

Social Cohesion and Self-Rated Health: The Moderating Effect of Neighborhood Physical Disorder

Increasing Police Presence: Examining Race, Ethnicity, and Perceived Neighborhood Disadvantage as Correlates of Support

Neighborhood disorder as a predictor of perceptions of firearm access: Examining peers effects

New Directions in Social Disorganization Theory

Examining fear and stress as mediators between disorder perceptions and personal health, depression, and anxiety