Abstract:Considerable debate in language acquisition concerns whether word learning is driven by domain-general (symbolically flexible) or domain-specific learning mechanisms. Prior work has shown that very young children can map objects to either words or nonlinguistic sounds, but by 20 months of age this ability narrows to only words. This suggests that although symbolically flexible mechanisms are operative early, they become more specified over development. However, such research has been conducted only with young children in ostensive teaching contexts. Thus, we investigated symbolic flexibility at later ages in more referentially ambiguous learning situations. In Experiment 1, 47 6- to 8-year-olds acquired eight symbol-object mappings in a cross-situational word learning paradigm where multiple mappings are learned based only on co-occurrence. In the word condition participants learned with novel pseudowords, whereas in the sound condition participants learned with nonlinguistic sounds (e.g., beeps). Children acquired the mappings, but performance did not differ across conditions, suggesting broad symbolic flexibility. In Experiment 2, 41 adults learned 16 mappings in a comparable design. They learned with ease in both conditions but showed a significant advantage for words. Thus, symbolic flexibility decreases with age, potentially due to repeated experiences with linguistic materials. Moreover, trial-by-trial analyses of the microstructure of both children's and adults' performance did not reveal any substantial differences due to condition, consistent with the hypothesis that learning mechanisms are generally employed similarly with both words and nonlinguistic sounds.

Ambiguity in Child Language: The Problem of Interobserver Reliability in Ambiguous Observation Data

Children's Use of Phonological Information in Ambiguity Resolution: a View from Mandarin Chinese.

Children’s Interpretation of Ambiguous Wh-Adjuncts in Mandarin Chinese

Phonetic Ambiguity : Approaches, Touchstones, Pitfalls and New Approaches

Ambiguities in Spatial Language Understanding in Situated Human Robot Dialogue.

To Know or Not To Know? Analyzing Self-Consistency of Large Language Models under Ambiguity

Ambiguity related misunderstanding and clarity enhancing practices in ELF communication

A Taxonomy of Ambiguity Types for NLP

Characterizations of Smooth Ambiguity Based on Continuous and Discrete Data

Semantic Ambiguity: Do Multiple Meanings Inhibit or Facilitate Word Recognition?

The Causal Structure of Semantic Ambiguities

Children's Interpretations of Numerically Quantified Expression Ambiguities: Evidence from Quantified Noun Phrases and Bare Cardinals

Cognitive Dissonance: Why Do Language Model Outputs Disagree with Internal Representations of Truthfulness?

Reasoning about Ambiguous Definite Descriptions

Symbolic flexibility during unsupervised word learning in children and adults

Consistency is Key: Disentangling Label Variation in Natural Language Processing with Intra-Annotator Agreement

We're Afraid Language Models Aren't Modeling Ambiguity

Ambiguity and Language Evolution: Evolution of Homophones and Syllable Number of Words

The Effect of Ambiguity Awareness on Second Language Learners’ Prosodic Disambiguation

Sensing Ambiguity in Henry James' "The Turn of the Screw"

Ambiguous language and common priors