Abstract:Feedback is an integral part of education and there is a substantial body of trials exploring and confirming its effect on learning. This evidence base comes mostly from studies of compulsory school age children; there is very little evidence to support effective feedback practice at higher education, beyond the frameworks and strategies advocated by those claiming expertise in the area. This systematic review aims to address this gap. We review causal evidence from trials of feedback and formative assessment in higher education. Although the evidence base is currently limited, our results suggest that low stakes-quizzing is a particularly powerful approach and that there are benefits for forms of peer and tutor feedback, although these depend on implementation factors. There was mixed evidence for praise, grading and technology-based feedback. We organise our findings into several evidence-grounded categories and discuss the next steps for the field and evidence-informed feedback practice in universities.Context and implications Rationale for this studyTo gain a better understanding of effective formative assessment and feedback approaches in higher education (HE). To promote a more evidence-informed approach to teaching and learning in universities. Why the new findings matterThe findings highlight a small number of promising strategies for formative assessment and feedback in HE. They also draw attention to a lack of (quality) evidence in this area overall. Implications for policy-makers and practitionersUniversities and their regulators/funders should be encouraging and supporting more, high-quality research in this important area. Researchers in the field also need to look to developing more ambitious, higher-quality studies which are likely to provide robust, causal conclusions about academic effectiveness (or other outcomes). Those involved in teaching and learning in university should use the findings to inform evidence-informed approaches to formative assessment and feedback and to challenge approaches which do not appear to have foundations in strong evidence. Students could be made more aware of teaching and learning approaches that are likely to support their academic progress.

Feedback That Leads to Improvement in Student Essays: Testing the Hypothesis that “Where to Next” Feedback is Most Powerful

Comparative Study about the Impacts of Chinese Automated Writing Evaluation (AWE) Feedback and Teacher Feedback on Middle School Students’ Writing Practice

Are they using my feedback? The extent of students’ feedback use has a large impact on subsequent academic performance

Does the Feedback Feed Forward? Student Response to and Views of Teacher Feedback in an EFL Academic Writing Class

Improving the student learning experience through dialogic feed-forward assessment

From feedback to revisions: Effects of feedback features and perceptions

Automated feedback and writing: a multi-level meta-analysis of effects on students' performance

The power of teacher feedback in affecting student learning and achievement: insights from students’ perspective

From copying to learning: using exemplars to engage students with assessment criteria and feedback

The Power of Feedback

Understanding the Difference Between Self-Feedback and Peer Feedback: A Comparative Study of Their Effects on Undergraduate Students' Writing Improvement

Inside the Next Black Box: Examining Students’ Responses to Teacher Feedback in a Formative Assessment Context

Peer-to-peer dialogue about teachers’ written feedback enhances students’ understanding on how to improve writing skills

Automated Essay Feedback Generation and Its Impact on Revision

Investigating the Essential of Meaningful Automated Formative Feedback for Programming Assignments

Feedback 2.0 in online writing instruction: Combining audio-visual and text-based commentary to enhance student revision and writing competency

The Study of Feedback in Writing from College English Teachers and Artificial Intelligence Platform Based on Mixed Method Teaching.

Thirteen Strategies to Increase the Impact of Assignment Feedback

The Power of Feedback Revisited: A Meta-Analysis of Educational Feedback Research

Using "just in time" online feedback to improve first year undergraduate nursing students' essay writing performance

Formative assessment and feedback for learning in higher education: A systematic review