Abstract:Purpose: This study is part of a larger study of 18 aspiring school leaders that aims to understand how gender identity and gender performance impacted their experience in the K–12 independent school leadership pipeline. One of the key findings was that meritocracy played an important role in how individuals understood what the outcomes of their ascent to leadership should be. This article focuses on that finding through the voices of aspiring K–12 independent school leaders who have tried to enter the pipeline or have come through the pipeline. Method: This study uses Carol Gilligan’s Listening Guide method of data analysis. It was important to use a method and frame the study in a methodology that enabled marginalized voices to be heard. The Listening Guide requires the research to go through three “listenings” of the data: listening to the landscape, where the researcher takes note of everything that was said in the interview and what was not said; listening for the I, where the researcher makes I poems out of all of the I statements in the interview to hear for a deeper layer of consciousness; and finally, listening for contrapuntal voices, which acknowledges that people speak in multiple voices. Through these three listenings, a voice emerged from the data of the keepers of the flame: White women believed that specific work would guarantee them access to leadership. Findings: White women believe and are complicit in upholding meritocracy while White men articulated meritocracy as a lie that they benefit from. One of the interviewees, Joe, was unique among the men I interviewed—he was the only sitting head of school that I interviewed, and he was the only man who spoke so pointedly about the leadership pipeline advantaging someone like him. Black women, on the other hand, have always known from their racialized and gendered experience of the world that their hard work will be overlooked. This also came through in study interviews with Black women aspiring to leadership. For them, keeping silent is an issue of survival. As Carol Gilligan wrote, the story of women’s voices and women’s silences is not a simple one: It is not a question of one gender or race being above another. Rather, it is a story about resistance. An individual’s belief about how much work is necessary to gain access to leadership proves how White patriarchy centers the pipeline and either enforces silence or enables voice in one’s ability to move up. Meritocracy, and whether or not the individual believed it, turned out to be explicitly tied to one’s gender and racial identities. More diverse school leadership may lead to more equitable independent schools.

Dialogic Leadership for Social Justice: Overcoming Pathologies of Silence

Theory, Methods, and Practice to Advance Equity and Social Justice in School Psychology: Articulating a Path Forward

Social Justice and the Study and Practice of Leadership in Education: A Feminist History

Teaching for Social Justice: A Teacher Researcher's Journey and Evolution

Restorative Practices for Empowerment: A Social Work Lens

Diversity, Social Justice, and the Educational Leader Diversity, Social Justice, and the Educational Leader

Dismantling Racism in Schools through Anti-Oppressive Frameworks: The Pivotal Role of Leadership in Achieving Racial Equity

Shared Philosophies, Conflict, and Critical Reflection: Developing Productive Teacher Collaboration

Centering Equity and Caring in Leadership for Social-Emotional Learning: Toward a Conceptual Framework for Diverse Learners

Dialogic Problematization of Academic Integrity Education

Dialogue and the Good: Fingers Pointing at the Moon?

Silence as Political and Pedagogical: Reading Classroom Silence Through Neoliberal and Humanizing Lenses

Students encouraging other students' learning: Leadership shared metacognition in practice

Paths in Utopia: School as Holding Environment for the Dialogical Self

Keepers of the Flame: Gender, Race, and the Myth of Meritocracy in K–12 Educational Leadership

Reconciling self, servant leadership, and learning: The Journey to the East as locus for reflection and transformation

Paying Attention: Talking about Social Justice in a Reading Intervention Program

Leadership for professional learning towards educational equity: a systematic literature review

Examining the Impact of Dialogic Learning on Critically Reflective Practice

Making Sense of Social Justice Leadership: A Case Study of a Principal’s Experiences to Create a More Inclusive School