Abstract:Measurements of the silicon self-diffusion coefficients in olivine at high temperature show that the effect of water content on rock deformation is actually very small, not large as was previously thought. The long-standing assumption that water has a significant effect on geodynamical processes in the Earth's mantle through influencing the viscosity of quartz and other rocks is brought into question by a new study of silicon diffusion in olivine minerals. Silicon self-diffusion, which is thought to control viscosity in the mantle, was measured in mantle-like conditions of high pressure and temperature as a function of water content. The authors conclude that the effect of water on upper-mantle rheology is small, and that water is unlikely to cause the observed low-viscosity zone. In an accompanying News & Views, John Brodholt considers the implications of this work and the difficulties of matching experimental studies to the extreme conditions found in the mantle. Water has been thought to affect the dynamical processes in the Earth’s interior to a great extent. In particular, experimental deformation results1,2,3,4 suggest that even only a few tens of parts per million of water by weight enhances the creep rates in olivine by orders of magnitude. However, those deformation studies have limitations, such as considering only a limited range of water concentrations and very high stresses, which might affect the results. Rock deformation can also be understood as an effect of silicon self-diffusion, because the creep rates of minerals at temperatures as high as those in the Earth’s interior are limited by self-diffusion of the slowest species5,6. Here we experimentally determine the silicon self-diffusion coefficient DSi in forsterite at 8 GPa and 1,600 K to 1,800 K as a function of water content CH2O from less than 1 to about 800 parts per million of water by weight, yielding the relationship, DSi ≈ (CH2O)1/3. This exponent is strikingly lower than that obtained by deformation experiments (1.2; ref. 7). The high nominal creep rates in the deformation studies under wet conditions may be caused by excess grain boundary water. We conclude that the effect of water on upper-mantle rheology is very small. Hence, the smooth motion of the Earth’s tectonic plates cannot be caused by mineral hydration in the asthenosphere. Also, water cannot cause the viscosity minimum zone in the upper mantle. And finally, the dominant mechanism responsible for hotspot immobility cannot be water content differences between their source and surrounding regions.

Evidence of power-law flow in the Mojave desert mantle

New Constraints on Upper Mantle Creep Mechanism Inferred from Silicon Grain-Boundary Diffusion Rates

Small Effect of Water on Upper-Mantle Rheology Based on Silicon Self-Diffusion Coefficients

Effect of grain-size evolution on the lower mantle dynamics

Effect of Bridgmanite-Ferropericlase Grain Size Evolution on Earth’s Average Mantle Viscosity: Implications for Mantle Convection in Early and Present-Day Earth

Seismic evidence for widespread western-US deep-crustal deformation caused by extension

Mild-to-wild plasticity of Earth's upper mantle

Flow and Deformation in Earth's Deepest Mantle: Insights From Geodynamic Modeling and Comparisons With Seismic Observations

Deforming the Upper Mantle- Olivine Mechanical Properties and Anisotropy

High‐resolution mantle flow models reveal importance of plate boundary geometry and slab pull forces on generating tectonic plate motions

Gravity, topography, and melt generation rates from simple 3D models of mantle convection

Present‐day Plate Motion Constraint on Mantle Rheology and Convection

Revisiting evidence for widespread seismicity in the upper mantle under Los Angeles

Spatial Scales in Topography and Strain Rate Magnitude in the Western United States

Mantle Structure and Flow Beneath the Central-Western US: Constraints from Anisotropic Tomography

Evidence for Dehydration-Modulated Small-Scale Convection in the Oceanic Upper Mantle from Seafloor Bathymetry and Rayleigh Wave Phase Velocity

Crustal Magmatism and Lithospheric Geothermal State of Western North America and Their Implications for a Magnetic Mantle

Evidence for a Chemical-Thermal Structure at Base of Mantle from Sharp Lateral P-wave Variations Beneath Central America

Evidence for faulting and fluid-driven earthquake processes from seismic attenuation variations beneath metropolitan Los Angeles

Localized Anisotropy in the Mantle Transition Zone Due to Flow Through Slab Gaps

Effect of Rheology Structure on Flow Patterns Driven by Density Anomaly in the Mantle