Abstract:Anesthesia, critical care, perioperative, and pain research often involves study designs in which the same outcome variable is repeatedly measured or observed over time on the same patients. Such repeatedly measured data are referred to as longitudinal data, and longitudinal study designs are commonly used to investigate changes in an outcome over time and to compare these changes among treatment groups. From a statistical perspective, longitudinal studies usually increase the precision of estimated treatment effects, thus increasing the power to detect such effects. Commonly used statistical techniques mostly assume independence of the observations or measurements. However, values repeatedly measured in the same individual will usually be more similar to each other than values of different individuals and ignoring the correlation between repeated measurements may lead to biased estimates as well as invalid P values and confidence intervals. Therefore, appropriate analysis of repeated-measures data requires specific statistical techniques. This tutorial reviews 3 classes of commonly used approaches for the analysis of longitudinal data. The first class uses summary statistics to condense the repeatedly measured information to a single number per subject, thus basically eliminating within-subject repeated measurements and allowing for a straightforward comparison of groups using standard statistical hypothesis tests. The second class is historically popular and comprises the repeated-measures analysis of variance type of analyses. However, strong assumptions that are seldom met in practice and low flexibility limit the usefulness of this approach. The third class comprises modern and flexible regression-based techniques that can be generalized to accommodate a wide range of outcome data including continuous, categorical, and count data. Such methods can be further divided into so-called “population-average statistical models” that focus on the specification of the mean response of the outcome estimated by generalized estimating equations, and “subject-specific models” that allow a full specification of the distribution of the outcome by using random effects to capture within-subject correlations. The choice as to which approach to choose partly depends on the aim of the research and the desired interpretation of the estimated effects (population-average versus subject-specific interpretation). This tutorial discusses aspects of the theoretical background for each technique, and with specific examples of studies published in Anesthesia & Analgesia, demonstrates how these techniques are used in practice.

A Comparison of the General Linear Mixed Model and Repeated Measures ANOVA Using a Dataset with Multiple Missing Data Points

Linear mixed effects models for non‐Gaussian continuous repeated measurement data

Longitudinal Analysis in Occupational Health Psychology: A Review and Tutorial of Three Longitudinal Modeling Techniques

ANOVA for Longitudinal Data with Missing Values

Application of Repeated-Measures Analysis of Variance and Hierarchical Linear Model in Nursing Research

Bayesian Latent-Class Mixed-Effect Hybrid Models for Dyadic Longitudinal Data with Non-Ignorable Dropouts.

Repeated Measures Designs and Analysis of Longitudinal Data: If at First You Do Not Succeed—Try, Try Again

Comparison of Maximum Likelihood Approach, Diggle-Kenward Selection Model, Pattern Mixture Model with MAR and MNAR Dropout Data.

Selecting a linear mixed model for longitudinal data: Repeated measures analysis of variance, covariance pattern model, and growth curve approaches.

Bias in Longitudinal Data Analysis with Missing Data Using Typical Linear Mixed-Effects Modelling and Pattern-Mixture Approach: an Analytical Illustration

Missing not at random models for latent growth curve analyses.

Mixed Model Applications to the Analysis of Repeated Measures Data in Clinical Trials

Analysis of Mixed Linear Model for Repeated Measures Data with Time Varying Covariate and Approach of Proc Mixed

Mixed‐Effect Hybrid Models for Longitudinal Data with Nonignorable Dropout

Data Analysis for Repeated Measurements with Missing Values in SPSS and SAS

Statistical analyses of repeated measures in physiological research: a tutorial

LGM-based Analyses with Missing Data:Comparison Between ML Method and Diggle-Kenward Selection Model

The Analysis of Repeated Measures Designs Involving Multiple Dependent Variables

Bayesian Analysis of Longitudinal Dyadic Data with Informative Missing Data Using a Dyadic Shared-Parameter Model

Repeated-measure analyses: Which one? A survey of statistical models and recommendations for reporting