Abstract:Various programming tools, languages, and environments give programmers the impression of changing a program while it is running. This experience of liveness has been discussed for over two decades and a broad spectrum of research on this topic exists. Amongst others, this work has been carried out in the communities around three major ideas which incorporate liveness as an important aspect: live programming, exploratory programming, and live coding. While there have been publications on the focus of each particular community, the overall spectrum of liveness across these three communities has not been investigated yet. Thus, we want to delineate the variety of research on liveness. At the same time, we want to investigate overlaps and differences in the values and contributions between the three communities. Therefore, we conducted a literature study with a sample of 212 publications on the terms retrieved from three major indexing services. On this sample, we conducted a thematic analysis regarding the following aspects: motivation for liveness, application domains, intended outcomes of running a system, and types of contributions. We also gathered bibliographic information such as related keywords and prominent publications. Besides other characteristics the results show that the field of exploratory programming is mostly about technical designs and empirical studies on tools for general-purpose programming. In contrast, publications on live coding have the most variety in their motivations and methodologies with a majority being empirical studies with users. As expected, most publications on live coding are applied to performance art. Finally, research on live programming is mostly motivated by making programming more accessible and easier to understand, evaluating their tool designs through empirical studies with users. In delineating the spectrum of work on liveness, we hope to make the individual communities more aware of the work of the others. Further, by giving an overview of the values and methods of the individual communities, we hope to provide researchers new to the field of liveness with an initial overview.

Live Coding: A Review of the Literature

Exploratory and Live, Programming and Coding: A Literature Study Comparing Perspectives on Liveness

A Study of Editor Features in a Creative Coding Classroom

A Review of Introductory Programming Research 2003–2017

A review of introductory programming research 2003-2017.

Introductory Programming: a Systematic Literature Review

Learning and Teaching Programming: A Review and Discussion

Fifteen Years of Introductory Programming in Schools: A Global Overview of K-12 Initiatives

Coding and Computational Thinking Across the Curriculum: A Review of Educational Outcomes

Active Learning Methodologies for Teaching Programming in Undergraduate Courses: A Systematic Mapping Study

Tools and Techniques for Teaching Computer Programming: A Review

Towards Supporting Programming Education at Scale via Live Streaming

Navigating the Pitfalls: Analyzing the Behavior of LLMs as a Coding Assistant for Computer Science Students—A Systematic Review of the Literature

Review on teaching and learning of computational thinking through programming: What is next for K-12?

Impact of teaching computer programming using innovative pedagogy embedded with live online lectures and related tools: A randomized control trial

Metacognition and Self-Regulation in Programming Education: Theories and Exemplars of Use

Technology-Integrated Computing Education in Early Childhood: A Systematic Literature Review

The Gamification of E-learning Environments for Learning Programming

What Do We Think We Think We Are Doing?: Metacognition and Self-Regulation in Programming.

ClassCode: An Interactive Teaching and Learning Environment for Programming Education in Classrooms

Visual programming and computational thinking environments for K-9 education: a systematic literature review