Abstract:Data literacy is increasingly important in today's data-driven world. Students across many educational systems first formally learn about data in elementary school not as a separate subject but via the mathematics curriculum. This experience can create tensions in the priorities of learning and assessment given the presence of other foundational mathematics content domains such as numbers, algebra, measurement, and geometry. There is a need to study data literacy in comparison to these other content domains in elementary mathematics. To address this need, we developed a methodology motivated by thinking curriculum theory and aligned with international assessment framework, for comparative analysis across mathematics content domains. This methodology examined increasing levels of cognitive domains from knowing to applying to reasoning across mathematics content domains. Intended, assessed, and attained curricula were analyzed using Singapore as a case study, combined with broader comparisons to attainments in four East Asian countries in TIMSS, an international large-scale assessment. We found that learning in the data domain had very limited coverage in intended and assessed curricula in Singapore. However, compared to other mathematics content domains, the data curriculum placed heavier emphasis on higher-order cognitive domains including the use of generally difficult mixed data visualizations. This demanding curriculum in Singapore was associated with the highest attainment in the data domain among average 4th grade Singaporean students relative to students in four East Asian countries in TIMSS, as analyzed by quantile regression. However, lower-performing Singaporean students at the 10th percentile generally did not outperform their East Asian peers. We further found very limited applications of data in other mathematics domains or cross-domain learning more generally. Our study offers a comparative analysis of the data curriculum in elementary school mathematics education. While the data curriculum was cognitively demanding and translated to very high average attainments of Singaporean students, the curriculum did not equally help weaker Singaporean students, with implications on current discourse on equity–excellence trade-off in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) education. Our study further highlights the lack of cross-domain learning in mathematics involving data. Despite the broad applicability of data science, elementary school students' first formal experience with data may lack emphasis on its cross-domain applications, suggesting a need to further integrate data skills and competencies into the mathematics curriculum and beyond.

Understanding the Link between Computer Science Instruction and Reading & Math Performance

Using Distributed Cognition Theory to Analyze Collaborative Computer Science Learning

Designing for deeper learning in a blended computer science course for middle school students

The Influence and Relationship between Computational Thinking, Learning Motivation, Attitude, and Achievement of Code.org in K-12 Programming Education

Development, Implementation, and Outcomes of an Equitable Computer Science After-School Program: Findings From Middle-School Students

Teaching Computing to Middle and High School Students from a Low Socio-Economic Status Background: A Systematic Literature Review

How are Primary School Computer Science Curricular Reforms Contributing to Equity? Impact on Student Learning, Perception of the Discipline, and Gender Gaps

Primary school students' perceptions and developed artefacts and language from learning coding and computational thinking using the 3C model

Code to Learn: Where Does It Belong in the K-12 Curriculum?

Examining the Role of Parental Support on Youth’s Interest in and Self-Efficacy of Computer Programming

Affordances and limitations of teachers instructional styles when teaching computer science and computational thinking

Facilitating Mathematics and Computer Science Connections: A Cross Curricular Approach

Computer Science in Mathematics Preservice Teacher Education

Technology-Integrated Computing Education in Early Childhood: A Systematic Literature Review

Exploring the multifaceted roles of mathematics learning in predicting students' computational thinking competency

An exploratory approach for investigating the integration of computational thinking and mathematics for preschool children

Investigating Links from Teacher Knowledge, to Classroom Practice, to Student Learning in the Instructional System of the Middle-School Mathematics Classroom

Learning data science in elementary school mathematics: a comparative curriculum analysis

What international studies say about the importance and limitations of using computers to teach mathematics in secondary schools

Exploring the key influencing factors on college students’ computational thinking skills through flipped-classroom instruction

Do underprivileged youth find hope, sense of community, and perceived social support in computational participation? A socio-cognitive approach to computational learning