How are Primary School Computer Science Curricular Reforms Contributing to Equity? Impact on Student Learning, Perception of the Discipline, and Gender Gaps

Laila El-Hamamsy,Barbara Bruno,Catherine Audrin,Morgane Chevalier,Sunny Avry,Jessica Dehler Zufferey,Francesco Mondada
2023-06-01
Abstract:Early exposure to Computer Science (CS) for all is critical to broaden participation and promote equity in the field. But how does introducting CS into primary school curricula impact learning, perception, and gaps between groups of students? We investigate a CS-curricular reform and teacher Professional Development (PD) program from an equity standpoint by applying hierarchical regression and structural equation modelling on student learning and perception data from three studies with respectively 1384, 2433 & 1644 grade 3-6 students (ages 7-11) and their 83, 142 & 95 teachers. Regarding learning, exposure to CS instruction appears to contribute to closing the performance gap between low-achieving and high-achieving students, as well as pre-existing gender gaps. Despite a lack of direct influence of what was taught on student learning, there is no impact of teachers' demographics or motivation on student learning, with teachers' perception of the CS-PD positively influencing learning. Regarding perception, students perceive CS and its teaching tools (robotics, tablets) positively, and even more so when they perceive a role model close to them as doing CS. Nonetheless gender differences exist all around with boys perceiving CS more positively than girls despite access to CS education. However, access to CS-education affects boys and girls differently: larger gender gaps are closing (namely those related to robotics), while smaller gaps are increasing (namely those related to CS and tablets). To conclude, our findings highlight how a CS curricular reform impacts learning, perception, and equity and supports the importance of i) early introductions to CS for all, ii) preparing teachers to teach CS all the while removing the influence of teacher demographics and motivation on student outcomes, and iii) having developmentally appropriate activities that signal to all groups of students.
Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to explore the impact of elementary school computer science (CS) curriculum reforms on student learning, perceptions of computer science, and gender differences, and to determine the extent to which these reforms promote equity. #### Main Research Questions - **Impact on Student Learning**: How does teaching computer science content affect student learning? How does it impact equity related to gender and academic performance? - **Impact on Student Perceptions**: How does teaching computer science content affect students' perceptions of computer science and its teaching tools (such as robots and tablets)? How does it impact equity related to self-efficacy and gender? #### Research Background - **Importance of Introducing Computer Science**: In recent years, there has been increasing international consensus that teaching computer science (CS) and computational thinking (CT) is crucial for ensuring students' digital literacy in today's society. - **Structural and Social Barriers**: Despite the introduction of computer science education, structural barriers (such as unequal access opportunities) and social barriers (such as stereotypes) still exist, leading to differences in performance and attitudes among different groups. #### Methodology - **Data Analysis Methods**: Hierarchical linear modeling and structural equation modeling were applied to student learning data and perception data from three studies to assess the impact of computer science curriculum reforms on student learning and perceptions. #### Results - **Learning**: Exposure to computer science education helps narrow the achievement gap between low-achieving and high-achieving students, as well as reduce existing gender differences. - **Perceptions**: Students have positive perceptions of computer science and its teaching tools, especially when they believe someone around them is engaged in related work. However, although boys have more positive attitudes towards computer science than girls, the impact of computer science education differs between boys and girls: the larger gender gap related to robots is narrowing, while the smaller gender gap related to tablets is increasing. #### Conclusion - This study highlights the impact of computer science curriculum reforms on student learning, perceptions, and equity, and supports the following points: 1. The importance of introducing computer science to all students as early as possible. 2. Preparing teachers to teach computer science while eliminating the influence of teacher background and motivation on student outcomes. 3. Providing age-appropriate activities to signal inclusivity to all groups.