Abstract:Background Processed seafood products are not readily identifiable based on physical characteristics, which leaves the industry vulnerable to high levels of product mislabelling (globally estimated at 5–30% mislabelled). This is both a food safety issue and a consumer protection issue as cheaper species could be substituted for more expensive species. DNA barcoding is proving to be a valuable tool for authentication of fish products. We worked with high school students to perform a market survey and subsequent species assessment via DNA barcoding to investigate the accuracy of fish product names used by retailers in Sydney, Australia. Methods Sixty-eight fish samples, sold under 50 different common names, were purchased anonymously from two retailers in Sydney. Each product name was recorded and reconciled with the Australian Fish Names Standard (AFNS). Samples were DNA barcoded and resulting sequences were deposited in the online Barcode of Life Data system using the simplified Student Data Portal interface. Results Forty percent of the fish names did not comply with the AFNS, however, half of these were either spelling errors or vendors supplied more information than the standard requires. The other half of the non-compliant samples were given common names not listed on the AFNS. Despite this lack of standardization, DNA barcode data confirmed the retailers’ identifications for 93% of samples and 90% of species sampled. Discussion The level of mislabelling we report for Sydney retailers (7% of samples or 10% of species) compares favorably with the global rates of 5–30%, but unfavorably with the only previous DNA barcode fish authentication study for Australia, which found no confirmed mislabelling in Hobart. Our study sampled mostly Australian produce, only two retailers and no restaurants. Results of our limited sample suggest that although many Sydney fish retailers attempt to implement the voluntary fish name standards, the standards are inadequate. As Australia imports 75% of its seafood, and in other countries restaurants generally show lower levels of compliance than retailers, broader surveys are needed before generalizing these results. DNA barcoding is a powerful yet simple method supported by accessible online analytical tools. Incorporation of fish barcoding into high school science classes provided students with valuable firsthand experience in scientific research and drew together different strands of the NSW curriculum relating to genetics and sustainability. Given the techniques, equipment, and reagents are now readily accessible, we expect to see greater uptake of DNA barcoding technology by high schools, citizen scientists and consumer groups in Australia in future. However, there remains much scope for further development of DNA barcode diagnostics (both data and analytical methods) for commercial fish species.

DNA barcoding Australia's fish species

DNA Barcoding of Yellow Croakers (larimichthys Spp.) and Morphologically Similar Fish Species for Authentication

Could do better! A high school market survey of fish labelling in Sydney, Australia, using DNA barcodes

Eyeing DNA barcoding for species identification of fish larvae

Advancing DNA Barcoding to Elucidate Elasmobranch Biodiversity in Malaysian Waters

DNA barcoding of Scomberomorus (Scombridae, Actinopterygii) reveals cryptic diversity and misidentifications.

DNA Barcoding of Fishes from Zhoushan Coastal Waters Using Mitochondrial COI and 12S Rrna Genes

A complement to DNA barcoding reference library for identification of fish from the Northeast Pacific

Examination of sequence variations in partial mitochondrial 12S gene amongst damselfish species as references for DNA barcoding

Biodiversity of Demersal Fish Communities in the Cosmonaut Sea Revealed by DNA Barcoding Analyses

DNA barcodes of eight species in genus Sebastes

Skimming for barcodes: rapid production of mitochondrial genome and nuclear ribosomal repeat reference markers through shallow shotgun sequencing

Cost-efficient PCR based DNA barcoding of marine invertebrate specimens with NovaSeq amplicon sequencing

Next-Generation DNA Barcoding for Fish Identification Using High-Throughput Sequencing in Tai Lake, China

DNA barcoding for identification of fish species in the Taiwan Strait

Applications of DNA Barcoding in Fisheries: A Review

Pragmatic applications of DNA barcoding markers in identification of fish species – a review

DNA barcode reference library of the fish larvae and eggs of the South China Sea: taxonomic effectiveness and geographic structure

Developing a DNA barcode library for perciform fishes in the South China Sea: Species identification, accuracy and cryptic diversity

Assessment of fish diversity in the East China Sea hairtail national aquatic germplasm resources conservation zone using DNA barcoding

DNA barcoding of marine teleost fishes (Teleostei) in Cebu, the Philippines, a biodiversity hotspot of the coral triangle