Abstract:ASTM international standard practice E679 prescribes the use of a 3-alternative forced-choice (3AFC) method with an ascending concentration series for measuring odour detection thresholds. It recommends obtaining an individual’s threshold by geometrically averaging the concentrations at which the judge’s detection response reverses from incorrect to correct. The legitimate reversal point is defined by a stopping rule. Previous researchers have identified some methodological flaws with this calculation approach, relating to the use of stopping rules and the method’s unconventional definition of thresholds. The current study aims to empirically investigate these issues in more depth.Thresholds for three odorants were obtained for 100 judges. 1,8-Cineole, isobutyraldehyde and β-damascenone were tested in accordance with the data collection procedure of ASTM E679. Initially, thresholds were estimated by the ASTM-based method with four different stopping rules. These estimates were subsequently compared against thresholds estimated by an alternative method; that of fitting psychometric functions. The theoretical grounds on which the latter method is based, and the clear connection between performance and stimulus concentration that it demonstrates, provide a thorough comparison of both conventionally-defined thresholds and method-independent thresholds against the ASTM-based method.Comparisons between the thresholds resulting from the various estimation methods demonstrated (1) the choice of stopping rule had a significant effect on threshold estimates (P<.05); (2) each stopping rule measured a specific level of performance, indicating a useful correspondence between the stopping rules and the psychometric function. These findings provide supporting evidence for the continued use of the ASTM-based method; albeit, if the stopping rule is standardized. One of the tested stopping rules (Stop 3) provided threshold estimates consistent with those estimated for d′=1.0, and is therefore recommended for future research.

SOME COMMENTS ON THE ESTIMATION OF SENSORY THRESHOLD BY KAERBER AND SCOVILLE METHODS

Improved Algorithm for Estimating the Optical Properties of Food Products Using Spatially-Resolved Diffuse Reflectance

The Relationship Between Scoville Units and the Suprathreshold Intensity of Sweeteners and Sichuan Pepper Oleoresins

The Correlation of Taste and Chemesthetic Sensation in Individuals with Different Suprathreshold Sensitivities

Two Rapid Odor Threshold Methods Compared to a Modified Method of Constant Stimuli

Determining odour detection thresholds: Incorporating a method-independent definition into the implementation of ASTM E679

Broadening the Scope of Food Quality Control: a Calibration Transfer Strategy for Minimizing External Influences on Spectral Analysis

Odor Thresholds by Forced-Choice Dynamic Triangle Olfactometry: Reproducibility and Methods of Calculation

Individual differences in sensory threshold for aroma chemicals added to beer

Evaluation of threshold limit methods for sensory data

COMPARISON OF TWO SIMPLE METHODS FOR THE MEASUREMENT OF DETECTION THRESHOLDS FOR BASIC, UMAMI AND METALLIC TASTES

The hedonic thresholds methodology varying two stimuli: Extending the range of sensory threshold applications

Determination of Absolute Threshold and Just Noticeable Difference in the Sensory Perception of Pungency

From chemosensory thresholds to whole body exposures-experimental approaches evaluating chemosensory effects of chemicals

Validation of Optimization Methods for Sensory Characteristics Using Rate-All-That-Apply and Intensity Scales: A Case Study of Apple Juice

Application of Sensory Evaluation, HS‐SPME GC‐MS, E‐Nose, and E‐Tongue for Quality Detection in Citrus Fruits

Comparison of Spectral Clustering, K-clustering and Hierarchical Clustering on E-Nose Datasets: Application to the Recognition of Material Freshness, Adulteration Levels and Pretreatment Approaches for Tomato Juices

[Quantification of astringency for traditional Chinese medicine based on animal preference index and electronic tongue]

Strategies for the content determination of capsaicin and the identification of adulterated pepper powder using a hand-held near-infrared spectrometer

Variation in odor thresholds for l-carvone and cineole and correlations with suprathreshold intensity ratings

Conversion of the chemical concentration of odorous mixtures into odour concentration and odour intensity: a comparison of methods