Life cycle informed restoration: Engineering settlement substrate material characteristics and structural complexity for reef formation

Ralph J. M. Temmink,Christine Angelini,Gregory S. Fivash,Laura Swart,Reinder Nouta,Malenthe Teunis,Wouter Lengkeek,Karin Didderen,Leon P. M. Lamers,Tjeerd J. Bouma,Tjisse Heide

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2664.13968

IF: 6.865

2021-08-08

Journal of Applied Ecology

Abstract:<p>1. Ecosystems are degrading worldwide, with severe ecological and economic consequences. Restoration is becoming an important tool to regain ecosystem services and preserve biodiversity. However, in harsh ecosystems dominated by habitat-modifying organisms, restoration is often expensive and failure prone. Establishment of such habitat-modifiers often hinges on self-facilitation feedbacks generated by traits that emerge when individuals aggregate, causing density- or patch-size dependent establishment thresholds. To overcome these thresholds, adult or juvenile habitat-forming species are often transplanted in clumped designs, or stress-mitigating structures are deployed. However, current restoration approaches focus on introducing or facilitating a single life-stage, while many habitat modifiers experience multiple bottlenecks throughout their life as they transition through sequential life-stages.</p><p>2. Here, we define and experimentally test 'life-cycle-informed restoration', a restoration concept that focuses on overcoming multiple bottlenecks throughout the target species' lifetime. To provide proof-of-concept, and show its general applicability, we carried out complementary experiments in intertidal soft-sediment systems in Florida and the Netherlands where oysters and mussels act as reef-building habitat modifiers. We used biodegradable structures designed to facilitate bivalve-reef recovery by both stimulating settlement with hard and fibrous substrates and post-settlement survival by reducing predation.</p><p>3. Our trans-Atlantic experiments demonstrate that these structures enabled bivalve reef formation by: (1) facilitating larval recruitment via species-specific settlement substrates, and (2) enhancing post-settlement survival by lowering predation. In the Netherlands, structures with coir rope most strongly facilitated mussels by providing fibrous settlement substrate, and predation-lowering spatially-complex hard attachment substrate. In Florida, oysters were greatly facilitated by hard substrates, while coir rope proved unbeneficial.</p><p><i>4. Synthesis and applications.</i> Our findings demonstrate that artificial biodegradable reefs can enhance bivalve-reef restoration across the Atlantic by mimicking emergent traits that ameliorate multiple bottlenecks over the reef-forming organism' life-cycle. This highlights the potential of our approach as a cost-effective and practical tool for nature managers to restore systems dominated by habitat modifiers whose natural recovery is hampered by multiple life-stage-dependent bottlenecks. Therefore, investment in understanding how to achieve life-cycle informed restoration on larger scales and whether the method it is applicable to restore other ecosystems is now required.</p>

biodiversity conservation,ecology