A comparative analysis on the evaluation index of circular economy in Taiwan and Japan

Ming-Fu Ho,Huann-Ming Chou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003188513-18

2021-07-15

Abstract:The development of a circular economy is an effective way to reduce resource consumption, reduce waste discharge, and protect the environment. On the other hand, Material Flow Analysis (MFA) is the basis for national planning of circular economy building. Japan is an advanced country that introduced the Material Flow Analysis (MFA) indicators earlier. Japan passed the Basic Act on Establishing a Sound Material-Cycle Society in May 2000. With the said Act as the basis, the “Fundamental Plan for Establishing a Sound Material-Cycle Society” was set up. In addition, based on the MFA results, the government's future development goals were set. In the plan, three main indicators, namely, resource productivity, cyclical use rate, and final disposal volume, were adopted to disclose the situations for input, recycling, and output of resource in Japan's sound material-cycle society. Through the quantitative tracking of material flow in the region, various evaluation indicators of resource input, product output, and waste discharge in the region were accurately grasped, which facilitated the country's formulation of circular economy development policies and measures. This paper shows some sketchy judgement on the advantages and disadvantages of Taiwan and Japan's circular economy developments in the recent decade through relevant data collection method and a comparative analysis of the empirical data of three material flow indicators, namely resource productivity; resource recycling; and final disposal volume. Following the comparative analysis for the main indicators of Taiwan and Japan's circular economy, it was found that Taiwan indeed falls far behind Japan in terms of circular economy development. Japan is an advanced country with the highest resource cyclical use rate and the fastest circular economy development. As the saying goes, “An advice from others may help one's defects”, by learning Japan's circular economy development mode, it just may enable Taiwan to quickly enter the realm of a circular society. The development of a circular economy is an effective way to reduce resource consumption, reduce waste discharge, and protect the environment. Japan is an advanced country with the highest resource cyclical use rate and the fastest circular economy development. In May 2000, Japan passed the “Basic Law for Establishing a Recycling-based Society. The lower the final disposal amount, the more efficient an economy is on the resource utilization and the less pressure is put on the environment. In Taiwan, resource productivity grew slowly from 2006 to 2014, which increased by 54% in 2014 compared to 2006. Since the cyclical use rate represents the proportion of the total resources input in the country that are prepared for reusing and recycling, therefore, the higher the cyclical use rate, the higher the resource efficiency, and the lower the amount of waste disposal relatively; this is also an important issue that Taiwan must face in developing the circular economy.