Abstract:Background: Interventions to improve physical activity behaviour are a core part of public health policy and practice. It is essential that we evaluate these interventions and use the evidence to inform decisions to improve population health. Evaluation of 'real-world' interventions provide an opportunity to generate practice-relevant evidence, however these interventions are difficult to evaluate. Various guidelines have been developed to facilitate evaluation, but evidence about their effectiveness in practice is limited. To explore influences on evaluation practice in an applied context, we conducted a case study of Sport England's 'Get Healthy Get Active' (GHGA) programme. This was a national programme that funded 33 projects that were delivered and evaluated across England. The programme was chosen as it was designed to generate evidence on the role of sport in increasing physical activity and improving health. The study aimed to explore and appraise whether strategies intended to facilitate project evaluation, including funder requirements to use a standardised evaluation framework and specific data collection methods, were effective in generating evidence that enabled the programme to meet its aims. Methods: We applied a collective case study design involving 35 semi-structured interviews, and documentary analysis of multiple sources of evidence from 23 physical activity projects funded by GHGA. We applied thematic and framework analysis. We developed a logic model and mapped actual outcomes against intended outcomes. A narrative synthesis is provided. We discuss implications for the effective commissioning and evaluation of public health interventions. Results: We identified five main themes of influences on evaluation practices that can act as barriers and facilitators to good practice: programme and project design; evaluation design; partnerships; resources; and organisational structures and systems. These influences are context-specific and operate through a complex set of interactions. Conclusion: Developing a better understanding of how influences on evaluation practice can act as facilitators or barriers is vital to help close current gaps in the evidence-based practice cycle. Critically, organisational structures and systems are needed to facilitate collaborative decision making; integration of projects and evaluation across partners organisations; transfer of knowldege and insights between stakeholders; and more rapid feedback and dissemination.

Understanding Evaluation Policy and Organizational Capacity for Evaluation: An Interview Study

Exploring Organizational Evaluation Capacity and Evaluation Capacity Building

Organizational capacity building: Addressing a research and practice gap

Why Evaluation Theory Should Be Used to Inform Evaluation Policy

Exploring influences on evaluation practice: a case study of a national physical activity programme

Using a Complex Adaptive Systems Perspective to Illuminate the Concept of Evaluation Capacity Building in a Network

A Research Synthesis of the Evaluation Capacity Building Literature

Identifying areas and approaches for improving evaluation processes in environmental education in the United States of America

Introduction: The evaluation of policies, programs, and practices

Policy implementation and outcome evaluation: establishing a framework and expanding capacity for advocacy organizations to assess the impact of their work in public policy

Empowerment Evaluation: A Practical Strategy for Promoting Stakeholder Inclusion and Process Ownership

Examining Conditions that Influence Evaluation use within a Humanitarian Non-Governmental Organization in Burkina Faso (West Africa)

Engaging evaluation champions: strategies to build evaluation capacity and promote data-informed decision making in youth development

The balancing role of evaluation mechanisms in organizational governance—The case of publicly funded research institutions

Evaluating a complex research capacity-building intervention: Reflections on an evaluation of the African Institutions Initiative

Developing a Framework for a Program Theory-Based Approach to Evaluating Policy Processes and Outcomes: Health in All Policies in South Australia

ICT4D evaluation: its foci, challenges, gaps, limitations, and possible approaches for improvement

Evaluation's role in enhancing organizational learning: A model for practice

Purposes and criteria in network governance evaluation: How far does standard evaluation vocabulary takes us?

A culturally responsive evaluation framework and its application in environmental education

Assessing the Effectiveness of Capacity-Building Initiatives: Seven Issues for the Field