Abstract:Studies in learning communities have consistently found evidence that peer-interactions contribute to students’ performance outcomes. A particularly important competence in the modern context is the ability to communicate ideas effectively. One metric of this is speaking, which is an important skill in professional and casual settings. In this study, we explore peer-interaction effects in online networks on speaking skill development. In particular, we present an evidence for gradual buildup of skills in a small-group setting that has not been reported in the literature. Evaluating the development of such skills requires studying objective evidence, for which purpose, we introduce a novel dataset of six online communities consisting of 158 participants focusing on improving their speaking skills. They video-record speeches for 5 prompts in 10 days and exchange comments and performance-ratings with their peers. We ask (i) whether the participants’ ratings are affected by their interaction patterns with peers, and (ii) whether there is any gradual buildup of speaking skills in the communities towards homogeneity. To analyze the data, we employ tools from the emerging field of Graph Signal Processing (GSP). GSP enjoys a distinction from Social Network Analysis in that the latter is concerned primarily with the connection structures of graphs, while the former studies signals on top of graphs. We study the performance ratings of the participants as graph signals atop underlying interaction topologies. Total variation analysis of the graph signals show that the participants’ rating differences decrease with time (slope = −0.04, p < 0.01), while average ratings increase (slope = 0.07, p < 0.05)—thereby gradually building up the ratings towards community-wide homogeneity. We provide evidence for peer-influence through a prediction formulation. Our consensus-based prediction model outperforms baseline network-agnostic regression models by about 23% in predicting performance ratings. This in turn shows that participants’ ratings are affected by their peers’ ratings and the associated interaction patterns, corroborating previous findings. Then, we formulate a consensus-based diffusion model that captures these observations of peer-influence from our analyses. We anticipate that this study will open up future avenues for a broader exploration of peer-influenced skill development mechanisms, and potentially help design innovative interventions in small-groups to maximize peer-effects.

Advancing higher-education practice by analyzing and training students' vocal charisma: Evidence from a Danish field study

Exploring Debaters and Audiences' Depth of Critical Thinking and Its Relationship with Their Participation in Debate Activities

Modeling Speaking Performance in Young Learners of Chinese As a Heritage Language: the Interplay of L2 Grit, Motivational Intensity, and Willingness to Communicate

Echo ‘our’ Voice? the Influences of Team Members on the Voice Behavior of Focal Employees

Getting Ahead by Speaking Up: the Moderating Role of Team Goal Orientation

The acoustics of charismatic voices in Korean political speech: A cross-gender study

Voice and Communication Training Program Improves Performance of University Students in Oral Presentations

The concept that went viral: Using machine learning to discover charisma in the wild

Influence of Age, Gender and Sample Duration on the Charisma Assessment of German Speakers

Role of the Big Five Personality Traits and Motivation in Predicting Performance in Collaborative Presentations

VoiceCoach: Interactive Evidence-based Training for Voice Modulation Skills in Public Speaking

Demystifying the Notion of Charisma: Micro-Ethnography on a Veteran-Teacher’s Classroom Practices

Good ideas for teaching: Design and implementation of the communication workshop "me as team member" for third-year medical students

Buildup of speaking skills in an online learning community: a network-analytic exploration

Performance-based assessment of students’ communication skills

Developing Listening and Oral Expression Skills: Pillars of Influential Oral Communication

Increasing Oral Communication Self-Efficacy Improves Oral Communication and General Academic Performance

Increasing Student Self-Efficacy: A Case for Assigning Oral Communication Activities before Written Assignments

How Does a Student-Centered Course on Communication and Professional Skills Impact Students in the Long Run?

A Multimodal Predictive Model of Successful Debaters or How I Learned to Sway Votes