Abstract:We thank Dr Abraham and colleagues for their interest in our recent article on the comparison of different paradigms for provoking blood oxygenation level-dependent (BOLD) signal alterations in skeletal muscles.1 Correlations and differences between BOLD and transcutaneous oxygen pressure (TcPO2) measurements were investigated. A point-by-point response is provided below. First, TcPO2 measurements were performed in accordance with the instruction manual (PeriFlux System 5000 Extended User Manual ver. 1.70 to 1.79), which suggests a local heating temperature of 43°C-45°C in adults. In our study, the temperature of each electrode was set to 44°C. Second, BOLD and TcPO2 measurements were, respectively, normalized to their corresponding baseline values with the formula Xt/Xr, where “X” is or TcPO2, “t” the time when the variable is to be determined, and “r” the resting value. Normalization was performed to test the association between BOLD and TcPO2 measurements, similar to the method used in previous studies.2, 3 As Dr Abraham and colleagues noted, normalization by using the absolute change relative to rest instead of the percentage is more reliable for TcPO2. In a secondary analysis, we assessed the absolute changes of BOLD and TcPO2 values using the resting value as the reference. Similar results were obtained and the Pearson correlation coefficients between normalized and TcPO2 values were 0.975 (P < .001), 0.298 (P = .035), and −0.931 (P < .001) in the ischemic, hyperemic, and post-exercise periods, respectively. Third, we agree that the slow response of TcPO2 to hyperemia, compared with BOLD , can be explained by the slow response characteristics of TcPO2 electrodes. Besides, time is needed for oxygen to freely diffuse to the skin surface underneath the electrode. On the contrary, BOLD measures oxygenation status at the deep tissue level. Instant oxygenation change during hyperemia can be captured by high-temporal-resolution dynamic MRI. Fourth, the atmosphere with pure O2 saturates the hemoglobin and the excess O2 molecules remain dissolved in the plasma, therefore increasing arterial PO2. Increased PO2 facilitates the diffusion of O2 from blood vessels to the skin surface, leading to an increased TcPO2.4 Further research using other techniques such as near infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) may help understand the mechanism for BOLD response under stress conditions. Fifth, all enrolled volunteers were healthy without lower extremity artery disease or other cardiovascular diseases. Both BOLD and TcPO2 measurements were averaged over all young and elderly volunteers to conduct the correlation analysis and draw Figure 3 illustrated in Suo et al.1 After separating young and elderly subjects, we can see that both post-exercise TcPO2 measurements were lower than resting values and showed an increase trend after exercise, though TcPO2 measurements of young subjects seemed to return to resting state earlier (Figure 1). The current study used a plantar dorsiflexion exercise pattern without use of a treadmill or other exercise equipment. Subjects were asked to lie down in the supine position on the scanner table with their lower extremities immobilized in the imaging coil during exercise loading. Therefore, the exercise was mainly confined to the local lower extremity and was not in a systemic manner. Reduced post-exercise TcPO2 measurements were also detected on healthy subjects in some previous studies in which similar local exercise pattern was used.5, 6 This phenomenon may be attributable to the fact that during exercise, the increased extraction of O2 in muscles would cause a decreased delivery to the skin surface and therefore a drop in TcPO2 recordings. We agree that the decrease from rest of oxygen pressure (DROP) index could be a more reliable metric to account for systemic PO2 changes with a chest reference electrode. Chest TcPO2 was not measured in the study and is warranted in our future investigations.

Correlation of MR changes with doppler US measurements of blood flow in exercising normal muscle

Arterial spin labeling perfusion cardiovascular magnetic resonance of the calf in peripheral arterial disease: cuff occlusion hyperemia vs exercise

[Proton spectroscopy of the lower leg muscles before and after exercise]

Correlation between skeletal muscle acetylcarnitine and phosphocreatine metabolism during submaximal exercise and recovery: interleaved 1H/31P MRS 7 T study

Exercise-induced fluid shifts are distinct to exercise mode and intensity: a comparison of blood flow-restricted and free-flow resistance exercise

Discussing of Cuff-Induced Skeletal Muscle Microvascular Perfusion of Lower Extremity by MR Multiple Sequences

Evaluation of skeletal muscle microvascular perfusion of lower extremities by cardiovascular magnetic resonance arterial spin labeling, blood oxygenation level-dependent, and intravoxel incoherent motion techniques

Concentric Exercise Effects on Skeletal Muscle Water T2 in Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (P2.131)

New Insights into the Spread of MRS-Based Water T2 Values Observed in Highly Fatty Replaced Muscles

Blood Oxygenation Level-Dependent Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance of the Skeletal Muscle in Healthy Adults: Different Paradigms for Provoking Signal Alterations.

Response to Letter to the Editor: “muscle Blood Flow, Oxygen Pressure, and Hemoglobin/myoglobin Saturation: the Infernal Triad”

Exercise-induced changes in intramuscular total creatine concentration measured with 1H magnetic resonance spectroscopy: A pilot study

Evaluation of Skeletal Muscle Perfusion Changes in Patients with Peripheral Artery Disease Before and after Percutaneous Transluminal Angioplasty Using Multiparametric MR Imaging.

Validation of Diffuse Correlation Spectroscopy for Muscle Blood Flow with Concurrent Arterial Spin Labeled Perfusion MRI

Phosphocreatine content and intracellular pH of calf muscle measured by phosphorus NMR spectroscopy in occlusive arterial disease of the legs

Methodological considerations on near-infrared spectroscopy derived muscle oxidative capacity

Different Energy Transfer Efficiencies and Buffering Capabilities in Quadriceps and Calves Muscles with Low-Load Isotonic Exercise Detected by Dynamic Localized Phosphorus-31 Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

Dynamics of capillary blood flow responses to acute local changes in oxygen and carbon dioxide concentrations

The Relationship Between Blood Flow and Motor Unit Firing Rates in Response to Fatiguing Exercise Post-stroke

Assessing muscle-specific potassium concentrations in human lower leg using potassium magnetic resonance imaging

Short-term correlation properties of R-R interval dynamics at different exercise intensity levels