Abstract:Litigation has forced tobacco companies like Philip Morris to disclose more than 7 million internal documents, including previously confidential public relations plans. We draw from this archive, as well as from activist materials, to demonstrate that, despite vigorous industry efforts to thwart them, activists in this case employed strategies of values advocacy and inoculation and capitalized on economic benefits to persuade publics. This watershed case poses continued challenges for the 2-way symmetrical or mixed-motive theoretical model of public relations. Accounting for public relations activism and understanding its voice in influencing contemporary public debate requires that scholars move beyond this widely accepted model that stresses compromise between activists and organizations. An alternative rhetorical theory of activist public relations is posited to account for groups that refuse to accommodate opponents. The authors would like to thank the various reviewers, as well as colleagues Drs. Rachel L. Holloway, Alan R. Freitag, and Dean Kruckeberg for their assistance with this manuscript. They would also like to thank Pete Bialick, President of Colorado GASP, for access to the group's archives. Notes 1The Excellence Study and research program is funded by the International Association of Business Communicators (IABC) Research Foundation to examine excellence in public relations. Part of the Excellence Theory that emerged from this program of research builds from the original four models to stress creating relationships between organizations and their publics that are two-way and symmetrical. 2The Excellence Study update rebuts ongoing criticism of the models. The authors contend they never argued that symmetrical practices were completely altruistic; they dismiss contingent and mixed-motive critiques as merely elaborating on their original conceptualizations of the theory; they contend that the two-way symmetrical model is not idealistic. They also dismiss the concern over abuse of power in the model, arguing activists can have considerable power by professionally employing public relations skills. 3This research was partially supported by a grant from the National Institutes of Health/National Cancer Institute (R01-CA87490), “Linguistic Analyses of Tobacco Industry Documents.” The views expressed herein are solely those of the authors. 4Cutler (Citation2004) argued that the process of theory development is being dominated by quantitative research such as that of Grunig's Excellence Study. 5The American Legacy Foundation's campaign, truth™, for example, persuades youth to reject tobacco by using values advocacy. Similar to GASP, truth™ focuses on the industry's dishonesty and social costs of tobacco, rather than on the dangers of smoking, to appeal to teens. 6Note, however, these commercials remain suspect for actually encouraging youth smoking under the pretense of preaching “adult choice.” See Landman, Ling, and Glantz (Citation2002).

Problems of evaluation: lessons from a Smokebusters campaign

Implementation of a peer-led school based smoking prevention programme: a mixed methods process evaluation

Evaluation of three smoke detector promotion programs

Mass media campaigns and the ‘file drawer problem’: A mixed methods study of how to avoid campaign failure

Reintroducing face-to-face support alongside remote support to form a hybrid stop smoking service in England: a formative mixed methods evaluation

A process evaluation model for patient education programs for pregnant smokers

A call to action for undertaking and sharing formative evaluations of public health campaigns

Public Health Messaging During Extreme Smoke Events: Are We Hitting the Mark?

Evaluating the Impact and Effectiveness of Flint's Community Ethics Review Board (CBOP-CERB): A Pilot Study

Effectiveness of a worksite smoking cessation program in the military. Program evaluation

Evaluation of a Tobacco Treatment Training Program

Healthy settings: challenges to generating evidence of effectiveness

Exploring mental health professionals' practice in relation to smoke-free policy within a mental health trust: a qualitative study using the COM-B model of behaviour

Safe inhalation pipe provision (SIPP): protocol for a mixed-method evaluation of an intervention to improve health outcomes and service engagement among people who use crack cocaine in England

Systematic review of randomised control trial health promotion intervention studies in the fire services: study characteristics, intervention design and impacts on health

Reflections on community-based population health intervention and evaluation for obesity and chronic disease prevention: the Healthy Alberta Communities project

Evaluation of feasibility and acceptability of a community pharmacy health promotion scheme - views of users and providers

Activism and the Limits of Symmetry: the Public Relations Battle Between Colorado GASP and Philip Morris

Smoking cessation interventions for university students: recruitment and program design considerations based on social marketing theory

Qualitative Process Evaluation of Urban Community Work: A Preliminary View

Facing the Realities of Pragmatic Design Choices in Environmental Health Studies: Experiences from the Household Air Pollution Intervention Network Trial