Abstract:Simple correlations play a large role in the analysis of psychiatric data. They are used to predict outcome, validate new instruments, establish treatment efficacy and find symptom patterns. Researchers and data analysts often face a question about which correlation coefficient to use in a study but are often unaware of the strengths and weaknesses of the alternative correlation measures. The presence of outliers, nonconstant variance, skewed distributions and unequal n are common in psychiatric data and this poses severe problems for many classic statistical methods. We compare Pearson, Spearman and Kendall's correlation coefficients using a large sample of subjects with schizophrenia spectrum disorders who were evaluated with 7 different psychiatric rating scales. Samples sizes ranging from 8 to 50 were evaluated using bootstrapping methods. The criteria for evaluation of the correlations were the type I error rates, power, bias and confidence interval width. Pearson's r did not always control for false positives at the nominal rate and was often unstable. Spearman's r performed better than Pearson's but provided a biased estimate of the true correlation. Spearman's r was also difficult to interpret. Our results suggest that Kendall's tau(b) has many advantages over Pearson's and Spearman's r; when applied to psychiatric data, tau(b) maintained adequate control of type I errors, was nearly as powerful as Pearson's r, provided much tighter confidence intervals and had a clear interpretation.

Estimates of the quantiles of kendall's partial rank correlation coefficient

Asymptotic behavior of kendall's partial rank correlation coefficient and additional quaantile estimates

Kendall Correlation Coefficients for Portfolio Optimization

On the Kendall Correlation Coefficient

Estimates of the Regression Coefficient Based on Kendall's Tau

On the Non-degeneracy of Kendall's and Spearman's Correlation Coefficients

Central Limit Theorem for Linear Spectral Statistics of Large Dimensional Kendall's Rank Correlation Matrices and its Applications

Influence function-based confidence intervals for the Kendall rank correlation coefficient

An adaptive test of the independence of high-dimensional data based on Kendall rank correlation coefficient

Limiting Spectral Distribution of Large Dimensional Spearman?s Rank Correlation Matrices

On eigenvalues of a high-dimensional Kendall's rank correlation matrix with dependence

Testing independence in high dimensions with sums of rank correlations

Limiting spectral distribution of large dimensional Spearman's rank correlation matrices

On kernel-based estimation of conditional Kendall's tau: finite-distance bounds and asymptotic behavior

Monte Carlo error analyses of Spearman's rank test

On Correlation Coefficients

Graphing methods for Kendall's τ

A Comparison of the Pearson, Spearman Rank and Kendall Tau Correlation Coefficients Using Quantitative Variables

Correlating and predicting psychiatric symptom ratings: Spearman's r versus Kendall's tau correlation

A simple consistent Bayes factor for testing the Kendall rank correlation coefficient

On The Error-Estimates Of Correlation-Functions