The combined effect of heterogeneous thermal conductivity, chemical density contrast, and heat-producing element enrichment on the stability of primordial reservoirs above the core-mantle boundary
J.M. Guerrero,F. Deschamps,Wen-Pin Hsieh,P.J. Tackley
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epsl.2024.118699
IF: 5.3
2024-04-26
Earth and Planetary Science Letters
Abstract:Earth's deep mantle hosts continental-scale enigmatic structures whose origin, characteristics, and fate are uncovered by advances in tomographic modeling, geochemical analysis, measurements of mantle mineral properties under extreme conditions, and novel methods in mantle convection modeling. Probabilistic tomography revealed that these deep mantle structures, dubbed large low shear velocity provinces (LLSVPs), are likely enriched in iron-bearing bridgmanite, making them denser than the surrounding ambient mantle (establishing a stabilizing negative buoyancy). A distinct geochemical signature observed in ocean-island basalts is thought to be sourced from the deep mantle, which indicates that LLSVPs may be candidates for a primordial reservoir enriched in heat-producing elements (promoting a destabilizing positive buoyancy). Using conductivity measurements from upper and lower mantle minerals, we derived a novel parametrized depth-, temperature-, and composition-dependent thermal conductivity model. With thermochemical mantle convection models, we demonstrated how the thermal state and total buoyancy of primordial reservoirs (as an analogue for LLSVPs) are influenced by a dynamically responsive and (spatially, thermally, and compositionally) heterogeneous thermal conductivity field. We examined the influence of moderate to high temperature-dependent conductivity models on the evolution of primordial reservoirs characterized by intrinsic chemical density contrast between 1.5 and 5% and heat-producing element (HPE) enrichment factors between 1 and 20. The lowermost mantle attains mean conductivities of ∼6 W/m/K within reservoirs and ∼9 W/m/K outside for moderate temperature dependence. For a high temperature dependence, mean conductivities are reduced to ∼2 W/m/K and ∼5 W/m/K, respectively. We found that heterogeneous thermal conductivity exacerbates the thermally driven effect of HPE enrichment, and the strength of the thermal contribution to the total conductivity is decisive in determining the long-term stability (> 10 Gyr of simulation time) of primordial reservoirs. For the parameter space we consider, the stability of primordial reservoirs with a particular HPE factor improves with greater density contrast. However, with a particular density contrast, stability decreases with a greater HPE factor. Thus, pile instability occurs for a combination of parameters that promote the domination of thermal buoyancy over chemical buoyancy. For a moderate HPE enrichment (factor of 10) and a highly temperature-dependent conductivity, reservoirs characterized by a density contrast ∼ 4% attain a mean density ∼ 1.4% and achieve long-term stability. For a moderately temperature-dependent conductivity, reservoirs characterized by a density contrast ∼ 3% attain a mean density ∼ 1.0%, consistent with tomographic estimates of LLSVP density and achieving long-term stability. When HPE enrichment is present, we found that a greater thermal buoyancy is more likely when temperature dependence is stronger due to the piles' larger temperature. Thus, a greater intrinsic chemical density contrast is required to maintain stable and long-lived primordial reservoirs.
geochemistry & geophysics