Using a Modified Brooks-Corey Model to Study Oil-Water Relative Permeability for Diverse Pore Structures
H. M. Goda,P. Behrenbruch,H.M. Goda
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2118/88538-ms
2004-10-18
Abstract:Abstract Understanding the significance of apparently different relative permeability relationships is paramount in the assessment of recovery efficiency for a particular field. Apart from the normal difficulties encountered in measuring relative permeability, Australian rocks tend to exhibit considerable diagenesis, often showing clay-filled pores (kaolinite or dickite). This means that fines movement and other related phenomena are often encountered, leading to non-representative testing results. More generally, relative permeability is a function of several key parameters: pore-scale geometry (including porosity and permeability) and pore distribution (pore-scale heterogeneity), rock-fluid interaction (mineralogy, capillarity and wettability), initial fluid saturation distribution, and fluid velocity (or capillary number, when combined with fluid viscosity and interfacial tension). In some cases more severe heterogeneity, e.g. layering or fractures, may be manifested. Also, defining suitable relative permeability relationships for a particular field requires validation and integration, particularly when conflicting data is available. This paper introduces a new Brooks-Corey type approach to study relative permeability data for diverse rock types, for both onshore and offshore Australian fields, with particular emphasis on geological aspects. Data from several fields and laboratory tests have been analysed, covering standard testing methods. General conclusions are presented regarding validation and integration procedures. This analysis is believed to be unique in terms of the wide range and amount of data analysed for Australian fields. As an aid to understanding, extensive use has been made of petrographic images, and some of these are presented. Introduction Reservoir description or characterization is recognized as an important activity in evaluating oil and gas reservoirs. This process may involve both rock and fluid testing. In homogenous reservoirs, such investigations may be relatively easy. However, in more heterogeneous reservoirs, the variation in rock properties requires more extensive experiments and studies in order to assign representative characteristics to individual rock types. By definition, any measurements other than porosity, grain density and permeability are considered as a part of special core analysis (SCAL). SCAL assesses the saturation-dependant and rock-fluid interaction characteristics. Capillary pressure and relative permeability together with wettability, are then of major importance for reservoir engineering SCAL. Relative permeability is a principal property that describes the simultaneous flow of more than one fluid. By definition, it is a dimensionless ratio between the effective permeability of a phase at certain saturation normalized either to the absolute permeability, or to effective permeability of the oil-phase at Swi. Relative permeability also depends on the saturation history, where the results from imbibition and drainage processes are not identical due to hysteresis effects. Ideally, experiments should be performed under reservoir conditions (pressure and temperature), utilizing representative core plugs and fluids. However, such experiments tend to be labor and time consuming and expensive. For these reasons, analytical or empirical-based relationships, derived from basic data (and certain assumptions) are often used by reservoir engineers as input for their simulation models. These analytical or semi-empirical relationships facilitate quick and easy implementation of relative permeability. The purpose of this paper is to show some results of an ongoing study that is reviewing a large amount of water-oil relative permeability experimental results from offshore and onshore Australian basins. A new Brooks-Corey type of formulation is compared with a previous Modified Brooks and Corey (MBC) model. This new formulation represents an alternative approach to study relative permeability. The paper also summarises various useful guidelines for dealing with experimental relative permeability data.