Huntington and Lovelock: Climatic Determinism in the 20th Century

Kent M. McGregor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2747/0272-3646.25.3.237

2004-01-01

Physical Geography

Abstract:Two scholars of the past century illustrate the changing yet lingering role of deterministic ideas in climatology. Early in the 20th century, Ellsworth Huntington wrote of the impact of climate on civilization and of climatic change on history and society. His claims were largely dismissed as being sweeping conjecture rather than demonstrable fact. Nevertheless, he was the leading proponent of the school of thought referred to as environmental determinism. His ideas received less attention as the discipline of geography moved in new directions in the 1930s. James Lovelock, writing late in the century, claimed that the Earth is a living organism capable of self-regulation. He called this the Gaia hypothesis. The idea of a living Earth was not especially new or controversial. However, he further suggested that the living Earth had powers of self-regulation, and that such cybernetic powers control the composition of the atmosphere and, subsequently, the temperature of the earth. Critics claimed that his proposed system was deterministic or teleological. Collectively, Huntington's and Lovelock's ideas demonstrate a range of deterministic theories in explaining the consequences of climatic processes and are relevant to current global change studies.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,environmental sciences,meteorology & atmospheric sciences,geography, physical