Where to next? A Systematic Review identifying the gaps in the Cognitive Literature regarding Attention and Working Memory in Early Childhood

RANA ALghamdi,Sheila Crewther,Jessica Peters,Melanie Murphy,Nahal Goharpey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.31219/osf.io/fu82w

2021-08-31

Abstract:Conscious, goal-directed behaviours in adults require attention and access to working memory (WM) and utilize the same visually driven parieto-frontal neural networks of the brain. Logically, the development of this goal-directed network must also underpin all learning and cognitive maturation.in children. Thus, we sought to systematically review the current literature relating to development of cognitively defined constructs of attention and WM in children from birth to 7 years old from the perspective of functional brain development. Abstracts were extracted from electronic databases (Medline, PsycINFO, EMBASE, Science Direct, and PubMed) and 24/4212 studies were identified as meeting the inclusion, risk of bias and validity criteria. Only 3/24 studies investigated visual attention in infants using preferential looking tasks and monitoring of eye movements. Twenty-one out of the 24 studies investigating attention in children aged 2+ years used visually based tasks that required participants to possess the ability to visually and auditorily attend to the presented stimuli, have adequate receptive language to understand and remember the verbal instructions, and WM and executive functions to respond verbally or manually. All studies found attention and WM to be significantly related. Few studies controlled for the inherent maturation of assumed cognitive skills or motor development, though a number have measured time required to perform a task. Further, there are very few studies in the literature where concurrent psychophysical, gaze tracking or brain imaging techniques have been used to investigate the functional neuroanatomy of attention and working memory networks in young children. Future exploration with more biologically and cognitively integrated paradigms are needed to clarify relationships between each aspect of attention and WM (verbal and visual), especially with respect to the timing and source localization of the temporal trajectory of neural activation during task completion.