Abstract:This article, written by JPT Technology Editor Chris Carpenter, contains highlights of paper SPE 201456, “Machine-Learning Work Flow To Identify Brittle, Fracable, and Producible Rock in Horizontal Wells Using Surface Drilling Data,” by Ngoc Lam Tran, SPE, Ishank Gupta, SPE, and Deepak Devegowda, SPE, University of Oklahoma, et al., prepared for the 2020 SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, originally scheduled to be held in Denver, Colorado, 5–7 October. The paper has not been peer reviewed. The complete paper demonstrates the application of an interpretable machine-learning work flow using surface drilling data to identify fracable, brittle, and productive rock intervals along horizontal laterals in the Marcellus shale. The results are supported by a thorough model-agnostic interpretation of the input/output relationships to make the model explainable to users. The methodology described here can be generalized to real-time processing of surface drilling data for optimal landing of laterals, placing of fracture stages, optimizing production, and minimizing frac hits. Modeling Approach In a multiwell field development, the ability to improve recovery efficiency per rock volume depends on well spacing, stacking, completion strategy, and avoidance of frac hits. In this study, the authors use surface drilling data to predict mechanical rock facies (generated using Poisson’s ratio and Young’s modulus) using several supervised classification methods. The objective is to use the trained model to predict the mechanical facies in real time using surface drilling data in future wells to optimize the well trajectory and placement of fracture stages. The highlighted modeling approach is conducted as follows: - Data preparation. Preliminary univariate (histograms, box plots) and bivariate analyses (cross plots) are performed, outliers removed, and missing values handled. The clean data are scaled, and a few additional derived variables such as mechanical specific energy (MSE) are added (also called feature engineering) that may boost predictive efficiency. - Unsupervised clustering. Clusters are generated using the derived variables of Young’s modulus and Poisson’s ratio. The number of clusters is optimized by silhouette width and within the sum of squares. The clusters group points of similar brittleness/fracability and are referred to as a geomechanical facies in this paper. - Supervised classification. A classifier is built using K-nearest neighbors, gradient boosting, random forests, and neural networks to identify geomechanical facies from surface drilling data. Seventy-five percent of the data are used for training and 25% for testing. Tenfold cross validation is performed on the training data to prevent overfitting. In 10-fold cross validation, the training data is subdivided randomly into 10 parts. The model is trained on nine parts and then validated on the remaining part. This process is repeated multiple times for each machine-learning technique. Only those models are averaged to provide the final model that gives good results for the validation data.

Utilizing Data-Driven Models to Predict Brittleness in Tuscaloosa Marine Shale: A Machine Learning Approach

Machine-Learning Work Flow Identifies Brittle, Fracable, Producible Rock Using Drilling Data

Machine Learning Models for Predicting Rock Fracture Toughness at Different Temperature Conditions

Robust machine-learning workflow for subsurface geomechanical characterization and comparison against popular empirical correlations

Machine Learning Approach to Model Rock Strength: Prediction and Variable Selection with Aid of Log Data

Thermal maturity and TOC prediction using machine learning techniques: case study from the Cretaceous–Paleocene source rock, Taranaki Basin, New Zealand

A new hybrid method based on sparrow search algorithm optimized extreme learning machine for brittleness evaluation

Machine Learning-Based Accelerated Approaches to Infer Breakdown Pressure of Several Unconventional Rock Types

Robust fracture intensity estimation from petrophysical logs and mud loss data: a multi-level ensemble modeling approach

Robust Machine Learning Predictive Models for Real-Time Determination of Confined Compressive Strength of Rock Using Mudlogging Data

Machine learning application to predict in-situ stresses from logging data

Application of Machine Learning to Predict the Organic Shale Sweet-Spot Quality Index

Analysis of Machine Learning Models for Prediction of Petrophysical Data

Machine Learning-Based Propped Fracture Conductivity Correlations of Several Shale Formations

Brittleness Evaluation Based on Shale Fracture Morphology

Predicting Triaxial Compressive Strength of High-Temperature Treated Rock Using Machine Learning Techniques

Machine learning for robust structural uncertainty quantification in fractured reservoirs

A new method to predict brittleness index for shale gas reservoirs: Insights from well logging data

Applied machine learning-based models for determining the magnitude of pore pressure and minimum horizontal stress

Leveraging petrophysical and geological constraints for AI-driven predictions of total organic carbon (TOC) and hardness in unconventional reservoir prospects

Data Engineering and Supervised ML Enabled Predictive Model for HPHT Fracturing Fluid Rheology - Digital Laboratory Approach