Enhancing the Reflexivity of System Innovation Projects With System Analyses
Barbara van Mierlo,Marlèn Arkesteijn,Cees Leeuwis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1098214010366046
2010-05-21
American Journal of Evaluation
Abstract:Networks aiming for fundamental changes bring together a variety of actors who are part and parcel of a problematic context. These system innovation projects need to be accompanied by a monitoring and evaluation approach that supports and maintains reflexivity to be able to deal with uncertainties and conflicts while challenging current practices and related institutions. This article reports on experiences with reflexive process monitoring (RPM)—an approach that has been applied in several networks in the Dutch agricultural sector, which strive for sustainable development. Particular attention is paid to conducting system analyses—a core element of the methodology. The first results show that system analyses indeed have the potential to enhance reflexivity if carried out collectively. However, regular patterns of thinking and acting within projects interfere in subtle ways with the new knowledge generated and limit the transformation of the reflexive feedback and insights into action.
social sciences, interdisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?