Abstract:Dual-process approaches of decision-making examine the interaction between affective/intuitive and deliberative processes underlying value judgment. From this perspective, decisions are supported by a combination of relatively explicit capabilities for abstract reasoning and relatively implicit evolved domain-general as well as learned domain-specific affective responses. One such approach, the somatic markers hypothesis (SMH), expresses these implicit processes as a system of evolved primary emotions supplemented by associations between affect and experience that accrue over lifetime, or somatic markers. In this view, somatic markers are useful only if their local capability to predict the value of an action is above a baseline equal to the predictive capability of the combined rational and primary emotional subsystems. We argue that decision-making has often been conceived of as a linear process: the effect of decision sequences is additive, local utility is cumulative, and there is no strong environmental feedback. This widespread assumption can have consequences for answering questions regarding the relative weight between the systems and their interaction within a cognitive architecture. We introduce a mathematical formalization of the SMH and study it in situations of dynamic, non-linear decision chains using a discrete-time stochastic model. We find, contrary to expectations, that decision-making events can interact non-additively with the environment in apparently paradoxical ways. We find that in non-lethal situations, primary emotions are represented globally over and above their local weight, showing a tendency for overcautiousness in situated decision chains. We also show that because they tend to counteract this trend, poorly attuned somatic markers that by themselves do not locally enhance decision-making, can still produce an overall positive effect. This result has developmental and evolutionary implications since, by promoting exploratory behavior, somatic markers would seem to be beneficial even at early stages when experiential attunement is poor. Although the model is formulated in terms of the SMH, the implications apply to dual systems theories in general since it makes minimal assumptions about the nature of the processes involved.

Passionate rationalism: the role of emotion in decision making

Cooperative versus competitive influences of emotion and cognition on decision making: A primer for psychiatry research

Emotional Theory of Rationality

The Rationality of Emotions: A Hybrid Process Model of Decision-Making under Uncertainty

The role of emotion in decision-making: a cognitive neuroeconomic approach towards understanding sexual risk behavior

Emotion, rationality, and decision-making: how to link affective and social neuroscience with social theory

The Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Emotion on Rational Person Behavior in the Decision Neuroscience Perspective

Risk and emotion: measuring the effect of emotions and other visceral factors on decision making under risk

Unreliable Gut Feelings Can Lead to Correct Decisions: The Somatic Marker Hypothesis in Non-Linear Decision Chains

Emotion and Reasoning in Human Decision-Making

Affective Dependency,Rationality and Reasoning from a Cognitive Perspective

Decision Making Under Objective Risk Conditions–a Review of Cognitive and Emotional Correlates, Strategies, Feedback Processing, and External Influences

Rationality, preferences, and emotions with biological constraints: it all starts from our senses

Risk as Analysis and Risk as Feelings: Some Thoughts about Affect, Reason, Risk, and Rationality

On The Brain And Emotion

Do emotions play an essential role in moral judgments?

Emotion: the Self-regulatory Sense

Research on the effect of emotion on decision-making

Risk Choice and Emotional Experience: a Multi-Level Comparison Between Active and Passive Decision-Making

Emotions as abstract evaluation criteria in biological and artificial intelligences

The Influence of Emotion on Fairness-Related Decision Making: A Critical Review of Theories and Evidence