Abstract:While anecdotes suggest that workplace gender disparities widely exist, the current literature on this topic has not provided sufficient causal evidence due to two deficiencies. First, because most gender studies rely on surveys and laboratory experiments, causal evidence of gender disparities in the field is rare; Second, because most empirical gender studies focus on individual workers or C-suite executives, research on low-level managers using real-world personnel data is also rare. In this study, we aim to address these deficiencies by empirically studying the effect of gender on the job assignment of frontline managers in a large sportswear retail chain using personnel, sales, and operational data. Our estimation strategy is a two-step fixed effects panel estimation framework, which 1) separately identifies manager fixed effects and store fixed effects by exploring manager switches across stores; and 2) estimates the effect of gender on store-manager assignment while controlling for the estimated manager fixed effects from the first step. This framework allows us to uncover causal evidence for the existence of gender bias in store-manager assignment—male managers were more likely than their female counterparts to be assigned to stores with higher sales potential, i.e., core stores, stores with a higher sales target, or stores with a larger number of sales clerks. To support this finding, we test three alternative hypotheses. First, we find that male managers achieved similar store sales when replacing their female counterparts in the same stores and vice versa, and male managers were not better at managing the turnover of sales clerks, neither of which supports an alternative hypothesis of differential managerial abilities; Second, we conduct a maximum likelihood estimation of a discrete-time Markov chain that models the processes of store-manager assignment and manager turnover, and do not find evidence to support the hypothesis that the observed gender inequity in store-manager assignment is driven by different gender preferences to leave stores with low sales potential. Third, we find that male sales clerks or male store managers on average made similar individual sales as their female counterparts, thereby not supporting a career selection bias hypothesis that men working at this retailer on average have higher sales abilities than women. Translating our findings into an actionable insight, we develop a gender inequity index (GII) to help organizations measure potential gender bias in job assignment. Applying this index to a simulation study using the retailer’s manager compensation data, we demonstrate the implications of gender-biased job assignment on the gender pay gap.

Driving Retail Cross-Selling

A Design Science-Based Case Study of Retail Chain Delivery Operations and Its Implications

Managing Revenue across Retail Channels: The Interplay of Service Performance and Direct Marketing

The Study on the Effectiveness of Sustainable Customer Relationship Management: Evidence from the Online Shopping Industry

Does the Effect of Customer Experience on Customer Satisfaction Create a Sustainable Competitive Advantage? A Comparative Study of Different Shopping Situations

Why Do Women Struggle to Climb the Corporate Ladder? Evidence from Retail Frontline Managers

Leveraging O2O Commerce for Product Promotion: an Empirical Investigation in Mainland China.

Operations strategy, business environment, operations resources and performance : an empirical study of retail firms in China

O2O switching determinants and successful drivers in omnichannel retailing services

Optimization of product marketing and management path of cross-border e-commerce enterprises relying on big data technology

Driving customer engagement and citizenship behaviour in omnichannel retailing: evidence from the fashion sector

Research on Online and Offline Marketing Synergy of Multi-channel Retailers——Case Study on Suning

Simulating Customer Experience and Word Of Mouth in Retail - A Case Study

Cross-channel Recommendation for Multi-channel Retail

Big Data-Driven Cross-Border E-commerce Platform Operation Strategy Based on Data Mining

Measuring The Effects of Online-to-Offline Marketing

Moving beyond the direct impact of using CRM systems on frontline employees' service performance: The mediating role of adaptive behaviour

Impact of customer loyalty and service operations on customer behaviour and firm performance: empirical evidence from UK retail sector

Sustainable Development In The Service Industry: Managerial Learning And Management Improvement Of Chinese Retailers

Keywords Selection in Search Engine Advertising with Cross Selling Effect

Leading Future Orientations for Current Effectiveness: the Role of Engagement and Supervisor Coaching in Linking Future Work Self Salience to Job Performance