Abstract:Background Unplugged programming is proved to be an effective means to foster the learner-centered programming learning. In addition to the final tests, learners’ programming knowledge, skills, and capacities are primarily demonstrated throughout the programming process, particularly in the situation when they encounter challenges and problems. However, few studies examine how learners engage in the programming processes and to what extent unplugged programming fosters learning. This research used a quasi-experimental design to investigate two instructional modes in China’s secondary education, namely, the instructor-directed lecturing and the learner-centered unplugged programming. Based on an analytical framework, this research used mixed methods to compare learners’ knowledge, behaviors, and attitudes under these two instructional modes. Results The research results revealed discrepancies between two instructional modes. First, learners in the unplugged programming class achieved significantly higher scores on the programming knowledge assessment, compared to learners in the traditional lecturing class. Second, compared to the traditional lecturing class, learners in the unplugged programming class had higher test scores of the computational thinking skills, particularly on the cooperativity dimension. Next, discrepancies of in-class behaviors showed that learners in the unplugged programming class had frequent behaviors of listening to the instructor’s instructions and discussing with peers, while learners in the instructor-directed class had frequent behaviors of listening to instructor, taking notes, and irrelevant activities. Learners’ self-reported attitudes in the unplugged programming indicated a higher level of confidence than learners in the traditional lecturing class. Overall, this research revealed that the learner-centered unplugged programming had potential to improve learners’ programming knowledge, behaviors, and attitudes compared to the traditional instructor-directed lecturing of programming. Conclusions As a feasible and easy-to-use instructional activity in computer science education, unplugged programming is encouraged to be integrated in formal education to increase learners’ programming interests, motivations, and qualities. This quasi-experimental research compared learners’ programming knowledge, behaviors, and attitudes under two instructional modes. The results revealed critical discrepancies between two instructional modes on learners’ knowledge gains, in-class behaviors, and changes of attitudes towards programming. Pedagogical and analytical implications were provided for future instructional design and learning analytics of computer programming education.

Effects of Personal Construal Levels and Team Role Ambiguity on the Group Investigation of Junior High School Students’ Programming Ability

Interactions of construal levels on programming ability and learning satisfaction: A case study of an Arduino course for junior high school students

Three Contrasting Pairs’ Collaborative Programming Processes in China’s Secondary Education

Single or Combined? A Study on Programming to Promote Junior High School Students’ Computational Thinking Skills

The Role Gender Differences In Computational Thinking Confidence Levels Plays In Stem Applications

Effects of a Pair Programming Educational Robot-Based Approach on Students' Interdisciplinary Learning of Computational Thinking and Language Learning

Investigation and analysis of the current situation of programming education in primary and secondary schools

Exploring Self-Efficacy of Students’ Computer Programming Learning

Analyzing Novice and Competent Programmers' Problem-Solving Behaviors Using an Automated Evaluation System

Research on the Influence of Technology-Enhanced Interactive Strategies on Programming Learning

Block-based Versus Text-Based Programming: a Comparison of Learners’ Programming Behaviors, Computational Thinking Skills and Attitudes Toward Programming

A Study on the Relationship between Student' Learning Engagements and Higher-order Thinking Skills in Programming Learning

Transitioning from Introductory to Professional Programming in Secondary Education: Comparing Learners’ Computational Thinking Skills, Behaviors, and Attitudes

Integrating online partial pair programming and socially shared metacognitive regulation for the improvement of students' learning

Investigating the Impact of Design Thinking-Based STEAM PBL on Students’ Creativity and Computational Thinking

Applying Online Content-Based Knowledge Awareness and Team Learning to Develop Students’ Programming Skills, Reduce their Anxiety, and Regulate Cognitive Load in a Cloud Classroom

Interaction of visual interface and academic levels with young students’ anxiety, playfulness, and enjoyment in programming for robot control

Comparing Learners’ Knowledge, Behaviors, and Attitudes Between Two Instructional Modes of Computer Programming in Secondary Education

Integrating Multiculturalism Into Artificial Intelligence-Assisted Programming Lessons: Examining Inter-Ethnicity Differences in Learning Expectancy, Motivation, and Effectiveness

To Cultivate Creativity and a Maker Mindset Through an Internet-of-Things Programming Course

A model for examining middle school students’ STEM integration behavior in a national technology competition