Abstract:Hintikka and Sandu originally proposed Independence Friendly Logic (IF) as a first-order logic of imperfect information to describe game-theoretic phenomena underlying the semantics of natural language. The logic allows for expressing independence constraints among quantified variables, in a similar vein to Henkin quantifiers, and has a nice game-theoretic semantics in terms of imperfect information games. However, the IF semantics exhibits some limitations. It treats the players asymmetrically, considering only one of the two players as having imperfect information when evaluating truth, resp., falsity, of a sentence. In addition, the truth and falsity of sentences coincide with the existence of a uniform winning strategy for one of the two players in the semantic imperfect information game. As a consequence, IF does admit undetermined sentences, which are neither true nor false, thus failing the law of excluded middle. In this paper, we investigate an extension of IF, called Alternating Dependence/Independence Friendly Logic (ADIF), tailored to overcome these limitations. To this end, we introduce a novel compositional semantics, generalising the one based on trumps proposed by Hodges for IF. The new semantics (i) allows for meaningfully restricting both players at the same time, (ii) enjoys the property of game-theoretic determinacy, (iii) recovers the law of excluded middle for sentences, and (iv) grants ADIF the full descriptive power of Second Order Logic. We also provide an equivalent Herbrand-Skolem semantics and a game-theoretic semantics for the prenex fragment of ADIF, the latter being defined in terms of a determined infinite-duration game that precisely captures the other two semantics on finite structures.

If Logic, Definitions and the Vicious Circle Principle

On existential declarations of independence in IF Logic

Alternating (In)Dependence-Friendly Logic

Definite Descriptions in Intuitionist Positive Free Logic

Definability in the Real Universe

Paradoxes of Definability, Russell’s Paradox, the Liar

Logic and Paradox

A Logic for Non-Monotone Inductive Definitions

Generalized Quantifiers and Natural Language

Avoiding Contradictions in the Paradoxes, the Halting Problem, and Diagonalization

Intuitionistic Fixed Point Logic

Paradox regained: Life beyond Goedel's shadow

An Axiomatic Foundation for the Logic of Inductive Generalization

Independent Set Readings and Generalized Quantifiers

A Logical Study of Some Common Principles of Inductive Definition and its Implications for Knowledge Representation

Logic as an internal organisation of language

Fregean abstraction in Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory: a deflationary account

Non-deterministic inductive definitions

Weak set theories in foundational debates

Logics of False Belief and Radical Ignorance

Proof-theoretic methods in quantifier-free definability