Abstract:The ability of density functional theory to predict the relative energies of different spin states, especially for systems containing transition metal atoms, is of great importance for many applications. Here, in order to sort out the key factors determining accuracy, we compare the predictions of 60 density functional approximations of 10 different types [local spin density approximation, generalized gradient approximation (GGA), nonseparable gradient approximation (NGA), global-hybrid GGA, range-separated hybrid GGA, range-separated hybrid GGA plus molecular mechanics, meta-GGA, meta-NGA, global-hybrid meta-GGA, and range-separated hybrid meta-GGA] for their ability to represent the spin-flip transitions of all 4d transition metal atoms of groups 3-10 (Y through Pd) and their singly positive cations. We consider all 16 excitation energies connecting the ground states (of the neutral atoms and the cations) to their first excited states of different multiplicities, and we also consider all eight ionization potentials. We also test the Hartree-Fock method. All density functional and Hartree-Fock calculations are converged to a stable solution, in which the spatial symmetry is allowed to be completely broken to achieve the lowest possible energy solution. By analyzing the fractional subshell occupancies and spin contaminations, we are able to sort out the effects of s orbital vs d orbital bias and high-spin vs low-spin bias. A reliable functional should have little or no bias of either type rather than succeeding for a limited subset of cases by cancellation of errors. We find that the widely used correlations of spin splittings to percentage of Hartree-Fock exchange are not borne out by the data, and the correlation functionals also play a significant role. We eventually conclude that SOGGA11-X, B1LYP, B3V5LYP, and MPW3LYP are the most consistently reliable functionals for balanced treatments of 4d transition metal atoms and their cations.

Approximate two-electron spin-orbit coupling term for density-functional-theory DFT calculations using the Douglas-Kroll-Hess transformation

Generalized Kohn-Sham Approach for the Electronic Band Structure of Spin-Orbit Coupled Materials

Structural Relaxation of Materials with Spin-Orbit Coupling: Analytical Forces in Spin-Current DFT

Density functionals with spin-density accuracy for open shells

Realizing Effective Cubic-Scaling Coulomb Hole Plus Screened Exchange Approximation in Periodic Systems Via Interpolative Separable Density Fitting with a Plane-Wave Basis Set.

Conceptual Insights into DFT Spin-State Energetics of Octahedral Transition-Metal Complexes through a Density Difference Analysis.

A correctly scaling rigorously spin-adapted and spin-complete open-shell CCSD implementation for arbitrary high-spin states

Consistent Second-Order Treatment of Spin-Orbit Coupling and Dynamic Correlation in Quasidegenerate N-Electron Valence Perturbation Theory

Low-rank approximations for accelerating plane-wave hybrid functional calculations in unrestricted and noncollinear spin density functional theory

Ab Initio Calculation of Coupling-Constant Averaged Exchange-Correlation Holes for Spherically Symmetric Atoms

DFT+ within the framework of linear combination of numerical atomic orbitals

How Evenly Can Approximate Density Functionals Treat the Different Multiplicities and Ionization States of 4d Transition Metal Atoms?

Direct Unconstrained Optimization of Molecular Orbital Coefficients in Density Functional Theory

Improvements in DFT Calculations of Spin–Spin Coupling Constants

Coupling-Constant Averaged Exchange-Correlation Hole for He, Li, Be, N, Ne Atoms from CCSD

Efficient Treatment of Relativistic Effects with Periodic Density Functional Methods: Energies, Gradients, and Stress Tensors

All-electron density functional calculations for electron and nuclear spin interactions in molecules and solids

Accurate and efficient treatment of spin-orbit coupling via second variation employing local orbitals

Polishing the Gold Standard: The Role of Orbital Choice in CCSD(T) Vibrational Frequency Prediction

Charge Conserving Approximation for Excitation Properties of Crystalline Materials