Abstract:Improved mentoring of midcareer researchers in medical schools has been identified as an important potential avenue for addressing low vitality and high burnout rates in faculty, and the scarcity of both underrepresented minority (URM) faculty and women in biomedical research. To address the need for widescale effective mentoring, we sought to determine whether a group peer mentoring intervention (C-Change Mentoring and Leadership Institute) for early midcareer research faculty was effective for different demographic groups in a controlled trial. Thirty-five diverse early midcareer faculty and 70 propensity-matched (PM) control subjects matched to intervention subjects on a) study inclusion criteria; b) gender, race, and ethnicity, degree, rank, years of experience, publications, grants; and c) pretest survey outcome variables, participated in the intervention. The C-Change Participant Survey assessed vitality, self-efficacy in career advancement, research success, mentoring others, valuing diversity, cognitive empathy, and anti-sexism/anti-racism skills at pretest and intervention completion. Analysis using multiple regression models included outcome pretest values and indicator variables for intervention, gender, URM status, and MD vs. PhD. Hypotheses regarding differential effectiveness of the intervention by demographic group were tested by including cross-product terms between the demographic indicator variables and the intervention indicator. Missing data were addressed using chained equations to create 100 data sets. The intervention participants had significantly higher (favorable) scores than PM controls for: self-assessed change in vitality; self-efficacy for career advancement, research, and mentoring others; cognitive empathy; and anti-sexism/racism skills. The benefits of the intervention were nearly identical across: gender, URM vs non-URM faculty, and degree MD/PhD, except vitality significantly increased for non-URM subjects, and not for URM faculty. Self-assessed change in vitality increased for URM and non-URM. The intervention worked successfully for enhancing vitality, self-efficacy and cross-cultural engagement across different demographic groups of biomedical research faculty.

Value of peer mentorship for equity in higher education leadership: a school of public health focus with implications for all academic administrators

Effective and inclusive mentorship in the field of epidemiology

Utilizing mentorship education to promote a culturally responsive research training environment in the biomedical sciences

Peer Mentorship in Psychiatric Nursing Education: Preparation for Future Practice

Students as Partners in Peer Mentoring: Expectations, Experiences and Emotions

On-site peer mentorship's effect on personal and professional development, stress reduction, and ease of transition into the medical education system

Group peer mentoring is effective for different demographic groups of biomedical research faculty: A controlled trial

The Nature and Evolution of the Mentoring Relationship in Academic Health Centers

When It “Feels Like a Giant Living Room”: Implementing Peer Education at an Urban, Research-1 Hispanic Serving Institution

Peer mentoring in an extracurricular music class

The importance of mentors and how to handle more than one mentor

The Benefits of Being a "Buddy": Exploring the Medical Student Experience As Mentor to Minority High-School Students

Developing Community-Based Mentorship: Supporting Health Science Training in Historically Marginalized Communities

Examining Mentor Perception of Competence in an Academic Peer Mentoring Program

Stanford Network for Advancement and Promotion: The impact of a community building-focused leadership development program on the success of underrepresented groups in academic medicine

Voices of educational administration internship mentors

Examining graduate student perspectives on supervision and peer mentoring across four professional faculties

Underrepresented in Medicine Trainees' Sense of Belonging and Professional Identity Formation after Participation in the Leadership Education in Advancing Diversity Program

The Power of Peer Health Education

Mentoring future mentors in undergraduate medical education

The Importance of Mentorship in Shaping the Careers of Academic Leaders in Plastic Surgery