Abstract:This study uses an experimental context to compare the results obtained from two well accepted scales that have been designed to measure stable personality traits - the Hurtt Professional Skepticism Scale (HPSS) and the Rotter Interpersonal Trust Scale (RITS). The RITS was developed outside of accounting, whereas the HPSS was developed specifically for measuring professional skepticism in accounting. Recently, the RITS has been proposed by Quadackers, Groot and Wright (2014) as a substitute for the HPSS on the grounds that the inverse of the RITS is a more useful measure of skepticism for audit purposes as it measures the presumptive doubt form of skepticism (Nelson 2009) rather than the neutral form of skepticism measured by the HPSS and is more responsive to risk information. To test this assertion, we created three case scenarios involving three different auditing tasks adapted from current literature. For each scenario, we administered both scales, varying the order of case and scale administration to monitor the stability that would be expected of measures of stable traits. Our findings indicate that HPSS and RITS measures of skepticism and trust, respectively, vary by case presented and order of risk tolerance measurement. Skepticism, as measured per the HPSS is not affected by the order of HPSS administration; however, it is affected by case and order of risk tolerance measurement. Trust, as measured by the RITS, is affected by order (timing) of RITS administration. Specifically, measured Trust decreases when the scale is administered after cases are completed compared to the level obtained when Trust is measured before the case is completed. RITS is also marginally affected by case and order of risk tolerance measurement. This study contributes to our understanding of the HPSS and RITS, challenges the reliability of both scales as measures of stable personality traits, and supports order stability for the HPSS, but not the RITS. Both scales may have components that are sensitive to states rather than being pure measures of traits. Also, HPSS and RITS do not appear to be substitutes for one another, as the RITS does not behave as the inverse of the HPSS across cases and orders of administration. Lack of trust (the inverse of RITS) does not appear to be synonymous with skepticism as measured by the HPSS.

Validity of Rotter's Interpersonal Trust Scale: A Study of Delinquent Adolescents

Cross-Validation of the Wright-Tedeschi Factors of the Interpersonal Trust Scale

Utilizing Dimensions of the Rotter Interpersonal Trust Scale in Investigations of Trust: Validation of Suggested Methods

Dimensionality of the Rotter Interpersonal Trust Scale

How Reliable are the Hurtt Professional Skepticism Scale and the Rotter Interpersonal Trust Scale for Audit Experimental Research?

Reliability and construct validity of 3 psychometric trust scales for women seeking substance abuse treatment in a community setting

A new scale for the measurement of interpersonal trust.

When Trust Fails: The Relation Between Children’s Trust Beliefs in Peers and their Peer Interactions in a Natural Setting

Is Mistrust in Early Adolescence Referent-specific? Looking at the Validity of Different Mistrust Referents in Sixth Graders

Performance of the Personality Inventory for Youth validity scales

Trust as an organizational knowledge sharing enabler – validation of the impersonal trust scale

Validation study of the Roberts Apperception Test for Children (RATC) in an adolescents' forensic sample

Preliminary Examination of Psychometric Properties of the Korean Version of the Specific Interpersonal Trust Scale

Trust under development: The Italian validation of the Epistemic Trust, Mistrust, and Credulity Questionnaire (ETMCQ) for adolescents

Interrater reliability of the motivation assessment scale: Failure to replicate with aggressive behavior

Convergent Reliability and Validity of the Questions About Behavioral Function and the Motivation Assessment Scale: A Replication Study

Development of the teacher rating scale of interpersonal problem solving in adolescents

Relating Facial Trustworthiness to Antisocial Behavior in Adolescent and Adult Men

Development and Validation of the System Trustworthiness Scale

Cross-Sectional and Longitudinal Associations Among Children’s Interpersonal Trust, Reputation for Trustworthiness, and Relationship Closeness

To Trust or Distrust Trust Measures: Validating Questionnaires for Trust in AI