Comparison of electric field strength and spatial distribution of electroconvulsive therapy and magnetic seizure therapy in a realistic human head model

W.H. Lee,S.H. Lisanby,A.F. Laine,A.V. Peterchev
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eurpsy.2016.03.003
2016-08-01
European Psychiatry
Abstract:Abstract Background This study examines the strength and spatial distribution of the electric field induced in the brain by electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and magnetic seizure therapy (MST). Methods The electric field induced by standard (bilateral, right unilateral, and bifrontal) and experimental (focal electrically administered seizure therapy and frontomedial) ECT electrode configurations as well as a circular MST coil configuration was simulated in an anatomically realistic finite element model of the human head. Maps of the electric field strength relative to an estimated neural activation threshold were used to evaluate the stimulation strength and focality in specific brain regions of interest for these ECT and MST paradigms and various stimulus current amplitudes. Results The standard ECT configurations and current amplitude of 800–900 mA produced the strongest overall stimulation with median of 1.8–2.9 times neural activation threshold and more than 94% of the brain volume stimulated at suprathreshold level. All standard ECT electrode placements exposed the hippocampi to suprathreshold electric field, although there were differences across modalities with bilateral and right unilateral producing respectively the strongest and weakest hippocampal stimulation. MST stimulation is up to 9 times weaker compared to conventional ECT, resulting in direct activation of only 21% of the brain. Reducing the stimulus current amplitude can make ECT as focal as MST. Conclusions The relative differences in electric field strength may be a contributing factor for the cognitive sparing observed with right unilateral compared to bilateral ECT, and MST compared to right unilateral ECT. These simulations could help understand the mechanisms of seizure therapies and develop interventions with superior risk/benefit ratio.
psychiatry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the differences in the stimulation intensity and focality of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) and magnetic seizure therapy (MST) on specific regions of the brain by comparing the electric field strength and its spatial distribution induced in a realistic human head model. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Evaluate the electric field distribution in the brain for different ECT electrode configurations and MST coil configurations**: This includes standard ECT configurations (bilateral, right unilateral, and bifrontal), as well as experimental configurations (such as local electrical stimulation for epilepsy treatment and mid - frontal line ECT), while simulating a circular MST coil configuration. 2. **Analyze the electric field characteristics under different stimulation current amplitudes**: The study examines the electric field strength and focality of various ECT and MST configurations under different current amplitudes, especially the stimulation intensity relative to the neural activation threshold. 3. **Explore how the relative differences in electric field strength affect cognitive side effects**: The study focuses on the different configurations of ECT (especially right unilateral vs. bilateral ECT) and MST compared to right unilateral ECT, in terms of the potential mechanisms for reducing cognitive side effects. 4. **Provide guidance for optimizing the dosage regimens of ECT and MST**: Through detailed electric field simulations, the study hopes to provide more precise dosage adjustment suggestions for clinical applications, in order to improve treatment effects and reduce adverse reactions. These research results are helpful for in - depth understanding of the mechanism of action of epilepsy therapies and provide a scientific basis for the development of interventions with a better risk - benefit ratio.