Information Technology: Brake on Progress

Michelle Ticktin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03017605.2016.1199620
2016-07-02
Critique
Abstract:IT infrastructure projects are socialised production activities developed in the public sector, notably in the US military, with private sector involvement. Given the movement towards monopoly and the concentration of the world’s firms into enormous enterprises (and by bringing other companies into exclusive relationships), IT projects are tending to grow in scale and complexity presenting management challenges even under ideal conditions. This is reflected in software engineering terminology, such as Ultra Large Scale systems and Systems of Systems. However, even the most modest of projects within small firms or departments, are now of such scale and/or complexity that adequate research, planning, project management, skills and incentives are crucial to successful delivery. Providing such a development environment for projects under capitalism is proving difficult for several reasons. The result is that teams become inured to low quality attainment (if not outright failure) and cynicism sets in. IT projects of large and small scale become forms of surplus extraction by monopoly suppliers, and purely an income to workers who see no opportunity for quality delivery and job satisfaction. IT projects, in part, appear to constitute social and economic waste. While IT presents humanity with profound potential for progress, that potential is stymied by capitalism itself.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?