Abstract:Trade liberalization during the neo-liberal era since the 1980s has been on the political agenda of many countries. However, in recent years and especially in the course of rising populist movements, protectionist measures seem to be gaining importance again. Nationalist economic policies challenge the overly positive view on economic integration and the reduction of trade barriers established by standard economic theory. In contrast to politicians, for quite a long time the great majority of economists explicitly publicly supported trade liberalization policies. In this paper, we show how trade and trade related policies are addressed and framed in professional economic discourses. Thus, we follow a mixed-method-approach and combine quantitative textual analysis with critical discourse analysis to highlight dominant narratives and imaginaries present in these debates. By analyzing more than 400 trade-related research articles published in high-impact economic journals we highlight three core trade narratives which constitute the elite economists trade discourse: First, “free trade cheer-leading” describes a clear link between the alleged lopsidedness of economists in favoring free trade (policies) in the public and academic debate. Second, “Ignorance in a world full of nails” relates to particular methodological and conceptual leanings in the profession, which seem to deepen the dominance of an overall positive evaluation of trade. And third, “success breeds exporting breeds success” postulates a positive causal relation between a firm’s economic performance and its export orientation. We conclude that the narrow perspective in economic elite debates prevents a more comprehensive understanding of the multifaceted challenges related to international integration.

Historicising Ricardo’s comparative advantage theory, challenging the normative foundations of liberal International Political Economy

David Ricardo’s Comparative Advantage and Developing Countries: Myth and Reality

Comparative Advantage and the Labor Theory of Value

Ricardo’s finances and Waterloo: legends by Samuelson and others lack historical evidence

Comparative advantage and trade liberalization in China

The Weberian ideal type in political economy: obsolete match or fruitful encounter?

International regimes, transactions, and change: embedded liberalism in the postwar economic order

Exploring the Trade (Policy) Narratives in Economic Elite Discourse

Comparative Advantage and Institutional Arrangement

Blind spots in IPE: contract law and the structural embedding of transnational capitalism

Robert W. Cox and the Idea of History: Political Economy as Philosophy

Latin American International Political Economy: contributions beyond the transatlantic divide

The role of role theory in international political economy

Competitive and Comparative Advantage: Towards a Unified Theory of International Trade

The Mesolevel Economy in Nineteenth-Century England and Wales: Applying Input-Output Accounting and Spatial Interaction Modelling to the Historical Study

Implied Comparative Advantage

The Export Of Capital To Colonies And The Falling Rate Of Profit In Economic Thought: 1776–1917

Thomas Edward Cliffe Leslie's Enthralling Journeys and His Critique of Ricardianism: From Inductive Political Economy to the Emergence of British Historical Economics

International trade and economic development: History, trend and application the validity of the comparative cost analysis

Seeing and Not-seeing Like a Political Economist: The Historicity of Contemporary Political Economy and its Blind Spots

Blind spots in IPE: marginalized perspectives and neglected trends in contemporary capitalism