Human or Humanoid Animated Pedagogical Avatars in Video Lectures: The Impact of the Knowledge Type on Learning Outcomes
Hamza Polat Nurullah Taş Abdullatif Kaban Halil Kayaduman Ali Battal a Department of Information Systems and Technologies,Atatürk University,Erzurum,Turkeyb Distance Education Application and Research Center,İnonu University,Malatya,Turkeyc Department of Educational Technology,Selçuk University,Konya,TurkeyHamza Polat is an associate professor in the Department of Information Systems and Technologies at Atatürk University,Türkiye. He earned his PhD in Computer Education and Instructional Technologies. His research focuses on human-computer interaction and instructional design,contributing to the development of effective educational technologies and learning experiences.Nurullah Taş holds a PhD in Computer Education and Instructional Technologies. He currently serves as an associate professor in the Department of Information Systems and Technologies at Atatürk University,Türkiye. His research interests include instructional technologies,gaming and gamification.Abdullatif Kaban holds bachelor's,master's,and doctoral degrees in Computer Education and Instructional Technology. He is currently an associate professor in the Department of Information Systems and Technologies at Atatürk University. His recent research focuses on artificial intelligence.Halil Kayaduman is an Associate Professor at Inonu University's Distance Education Center,is currently a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Eastern Finland,specializing in idiographic learning analytics. His research focuses on open and distance education,learning analytics,technology-enhanced learning environments,and human-computer interaction.Ali Battal is an associate professor at Selcuk University,Department of Instructional Technology,Türkiye. His main research areas are the use of 3D virtual worlds for educational purposes,programming education,gamification,human computer interaction and designing usable learning environments.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10447318.2024.2415762
IF: 4.92
2024-10-19
International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction
Abstract:This study examines the impacts of educational videos with human or humanoid animated pedagogical avatars (APAs) on cognitive, affective, and social learning outcomes in declarative and procedural knowledge contexts. A 2 × 2 factorial design was used, considering instructor type (human vs. humanoid APA) and knowledge type (declarative vs. procedural). The study involved 139 university students with no prior knowledge of the video content and was conducted in a human-computer interaction lab using an eye-tracking device. There were no significant differences in learning achievement, perceived lecture engagement, emotion, satisfaction, and social presence between the human and humanoid APA. However, learners showed greater visual interest in the human instructor, which influenced their interest in the learning content. Viewers of declarative knowledge videos showed more visual interest and achieved higher learning scores, while procedural videos increased lecture engagement, emotion, satisfaction, and social presence. The study suggests that humanoid APAs can effectively replace human instructors in educational videos and emphasizes the importance of considering knowledge types in video design to impact learning outcomes.
computer science, cybernetics,ergonomics