Abstract:The rapid growth of news dissemination and user engagement on social media has raised concerns about the influence and societal impact of biased and unreliable information. As a response to these concerns, a substantial body of research has been dedicated to understanding how users interact with different news. However, this research has primarily analyzed publicly shared posts. With a significant portion of engagement taking place within Facebook's private sphere, it is therefore important to also consider the private posts. In this paper, we present the first comprehensive comparison of the interaction patterns and depth of engagement between public and private posts of different types of news content shared on Facebook. To compare these patterns, we gathered and analyzed two complementary datasets: the first includes interaction data for all Facebook posts (private + public) referencing a manually labeled collection of over 19K news articles, while the second contains only interaction data for public posts tracked by CrowdTangle. As part of our methodology, we introduce several carefully designed data processing steps that address some critical aspects missed by prior works but that (through our iterative discussions and feedback with the CrowdTangle team) emerged as important to ensure fairness for this type of study. Our findings highlight significant disparities in interaction patterns across various news classes and spheres. For example, our statistical analysis demonstrates that users engage significantly more deeply with news in the private sphere compared to the public one, underscoring the pivotal role of considering both the public and private spheres of Facebook in future research. Beyond its scholarly impact, the findings of this study can benefit Facebook content moderators, regulators, and policymakers, contributing to a healthier online discourse.

Engaging with Political and Social Issues on Facebook in College Life

The Impact of Wechat on College Students in Ideological and Political Education

Supporting cross-cultural online discussion with formal and informal platforms: a case between Hong Kong and Taiwan

Engagement, Content Quality and Ideology over Time on the Facebook URL Dataset

WeChat use among Chinese college students: Exploring gratifications and political engagement in China

To Interact or Not to Interact with News Posts: The Role of Algorithmic Awareness & Self-Monitoring in Facebook News Consumption

Understanding Differences in News Article Interaction Patterns on Facebook: Public vs. Private Sharing with Varying Bias and Reliability

An Empirical Study of the Impact of Social Media Use on Online Political Participation of University Students in Western China

Understanding Audience Engagement with Mainstream and Alternative News Posts on Facebook

Political science. Exposure to ideologically diverse news and opinion on Facebook

Visiting Theories That Predict College Students' Self-Disclosure on Facebook

A study of social information control affordances and gender difference in Facebook self-presentation

Social Comparison and Facebook: Feedback, Positivity, and Opportunities for Comparison

Unpacking news engagement through the perceived affordances of social media: A cross-platform, cross-country approach

Exploring the Role of Social Media in College Students' Health Education: Opportunities and Challenges

Student-Initiated Use of Facebook for Learning Online Journalism

Keep Them Engaged! Investigating the Effects of Self-centered Social Media Communication Style on User Engagement in 12 European Countries

College Students' Health Information Activities on Facebook: Investigating the Impacts of Health Topic Sensitivity, Information Sources, and Demographics

“What’s on Your Mind?” Examining the Influence of Facebook User Motivations, Usage Intensity, and Public Self-Disclosure on Perceived Social Capital

Linking News Value Theory With Online Deliberation: How News Factors and Illustration Factors in News Articles Affect the Deliberative Quality of User Discussions in SNS’ Comment Sections

Communities Influence Social Media in Dealing with ‘Filter Bubbles’ and ‘Echo Chambers’ in The Era of Digital Content Among Students