Abstract:Feed-in Tariff and Renewable Portfolio Standard are the most widely adopted policies to promote development of renewable energy. The comparison of effectiveness of the two policies is the focus for theoretical and political study in the environmental economics area, especially when there is distortion caused by monopoly power in the electricity market. In this paper, we compare the difference between Feed-in Tariff policy and Renewable Portfolio Standard policy in promoting the use of green electricity generated from wind in an incomplete competitive electricity market through the analysis of a partial equilibrium model in which there are two kinds of electricity plants specializing in traditional electricity generation and green energy generation respectively. It is found that, in a duopoly competitive market, the FIT policy tends to be more effective in promoting green electricity generation than the RPS policy, since the latter leads to higher electricity price, thus reducing market demand for the green energy. The empirical test of the EU panel data from 2004 to 2011 shows that the FIT policy boosts the amount of electricity generated from wind significantly, while the RPS policy increases the share of renewable energy use in the EU with no significant effect on the amount of green electricity generation. The basic mechanism behind this is that although RPS leads to higher electricity price and lower electricity demand, it increases the share of green electricity consumption. Monopoly of the electricity market is proved to have a negative effect on wind electricity generation. Other control variables like electricity market size, technology and other renewable energy policies also have influence on the wind electricity generation as predicted. In a threshold panel data model, the paper finds that when the degree of monopoly in the electricity market is higher than 35%, which implies that the largest electricity firm in the country grabs more than one third of the market share, monopoly has a more significant negative impact on the green electricity generation.

Are renewable energy subsidies effective? Evidence from Europe

The diffusion of renewable energy production in European countries: the role of incentives

Does renewable energy policy work? Evidence from a panel data analysis

Renewable Energy Promotion with Economic Incentives: The Case of the EU

Effectiveness of renewable energy incentives on sustainability: evidence from dynamic panel data analysis for the EU countries and Turkey

Comparison of Incentive Policies for Renewable Energy in an Oligopolistic Market with Price-Responsive Demand

Economic impacts from the promotion of renewable energy technologies: The German experience

In my own or in their own way? Evidence on the diffusion of renewable energy promotion instruments

A Comparison of Renewable Energy Policies in Imperfect Competition Electricity Market

Do subsidies and R&D investment boost energy transition performance? Evidence from Chinese renewable energy firms

How feed-in-tariff subsidies affect renewable energy investments in China? New evidence from firm-level data

Subsidies and tax incentives - Does it make a difference on TFP? Evidences from China's photovoltaic and wind listed companies

Renewable energy subsidies: Second-best policy or fatal aberration for mitigation?

How Effective are US Renewable Energy Subsidies in Cutting Greenhouse Gases?

The Effectiveness of China’s Renewable Energy Policy: an Empirical Evaluation of Wind Power Based on the Framework of Renewable Energy Law and Its Accompanying Policies

The impact of environmental policy on renewable energy innovation: A systematic literature review and research directions

Welfare evaluation of subsidies to renewable energy in general equilibrium: Theory and application

Renewable Energy, Subsidies, and the WTO: Where Has the 'Green' Gone?

Sustainable Power Generation in Europe: A Panel Data Analysis of the Effects of Market and Environmental Regulations

The innovation effects of renewable energy policies and their interaction: the case of solar photovoltaics

Is green energy expensive? Empirical evidence from the Spanish electricity market