Abstract:Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs) comprise a rapidly evolving field of technology with the potential of far-reaching impact in domains ranging from medical over industrial to artistic, gaming, and military. Today, these emerging BCI applications are typically still at early technology readiness levels, but because BCIs create novel, technical communication channels for the human brain, they have raised privacy and security concerns. To mitigate such risks, a large body of countermeasures has been proposed in the literature, but a general framework is lacking which would describe how privacy and security of BCI applications can be protected by design, i.e., already as an integral part of the early BCI design process, in a systematic manner, and allowing suitable depth of analysis for different contexts such as commercial BCI product development vs. academic research and lab prototypes. Here we propose the adoption of recent systems-engineering methodologies for privacy threat modeling, risk assessment, and privacy engineering to the BCI field. These methodologies address privacy and security concerns in a more systematic and holistic way than previous approaches, and provide reusable patterns on how to move from principles to actions. We apply these methodologies to BCI and data flows and derive a generic, extensible, and actionable framework for brain-privacy-preserving cybersecurity in BCI applications. This framework is designed for flexible application to the wide range of current and future BCI applications. We also propose a range of novel privacy-by-design features for BCIs, with an emphasis on features promoting BCI transparency as a prerequisite for informational self-determination of BCI users, as well as design features for ensuring BCI user autonomy. We anticipate that our framework will contribute to the development of privacy-respecting, trustworthy BCI technologies.

Applying the IEEE BRAIN neuroethics framework to intra-cortical brain-computer interfaces

Ethical Issues in Brain–Computer Interface Research, Development, and Dissemination

Ethical aspects of brain computer interfaces: a scoping review

Bridging Minds and Machines: The Recent Advances of Brain-Computer Interfaces in Neurological and Neurosurgical Applications

Understanding the Ethical Issues of Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs): A Blessing or the Beginning of a Dystopian Future?

The Interplay of Computing, Ethics, and Policy in Brain-Computer Interface Design

Brain-Computer Interfacing: An Introduction

Bioethics of Brain Computer Interfaces

Ethical considerations for the use of brain–computer interfaces for cognitive enhancement

The evolution and application of mechanical instruments in brain-computer interface technology

Challenges and Opportunities for the Future of Brain-Computer Interface in Neurorehabilitation

Network-based brain–computer interfaces: principles and applications

Neural interface technology for human-computer interaction

Ethical and social issues behind brain-computer interface

Brain Computer Interface Technologies in the Coming Decades

Neuroethical Issues Related to Brain-Computer Interface Technology

A Framework for Preserving Privacy and Cybersecurity in Brain-Computer Interfacing Applications

Network neuroscience for optimizing brain-computer interfaces

Advanced Electrode Technologies for Noninvasive Brain-Computer Interfaces

Neural interfaces and human-computer interaction: A U.S. review: Delving into the developments, ethical considerations, and future prospects of brain-computer interfaces

Non-invasive Brain-Computer Interfaces: State of the Art and Trends