The Interplay of Computing, Ethics, and Policy in Brain-Computer Interface Design

Muhammed Ugur,Raghavendra Pradyumna Pothukuchi,Abhishek Bhattacharjee
2024-09-26
Abstract:Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) connect biological neurons in the brain with external systems like prosthetics and computers. They are increasingly incorporating processing capabilities to analyze and stimulate neural activity, and consequently, pose unique design challenges related to ethics, law, and policy. For the first time, this paper articulates how ethical, legal, and policy considerations can shape BCI architecture design, and how the decisions that architects make constrain or expand the ethical, legal, and policy frameworks that can be applied to them.
Hardware Architecture,Computers and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: how ethical, legal, and policy considerations interact with the technical architecture in the design of brain - computer interfaces (BCIs), and how these considerations influence the design decisions of BCIs. Specifically, the paper explores the following aspects: 1. **The influence of ethics, law, and policy on BCI architecture design**: - As a device connecting brain neurons to external systems, BCI not only involves complex technical challenges but also brings unique ethical, legal, and policy issues. - For example, during the design process, how to balance the efficiency and flexibility of dedicated processors to ensure that users' future treatment needs are met while avoiding frequent surgical replacements. 2. **Constraints or extensions of design choices on the ethical, legal, and policy framework**: - The paper points out that when architecture designers make design decisions, these choices will in turn limit or expand the ethical, legal, and policy framework that can be applied to BCIs. - For example, whether to support encryption to protect users' neural data requires a trade - off between the impact of energy consumption and thermal management on users' physiology. 3. **Upgradeability and compatibility standards**: - With the development of BCI technology, how to ensure the upgradeability and compatibility of implanted devices is an important issue. - Currently, there is a lack of clear minimum upgradeability or compatibility requirements, which poses a challenge to users' safety and rights. 4. **Security, access, and autonomy**: - The sensitivity classification of neural data, access rights, and protection methods are current research hotspots. - Designers need to consider how to support security measures such as encryption without affecting the main functions of BCIs and respect users' preferences and rights. 5. **Device ownership and data - sharing mechanisms**: - Support must be provided at the hardware or software level to ensure that users can control their own neural data and decide how to share the data. 6. **The autonomy of BCI devices**: - Explore whether BCI devices should have the ability to act autonomously, such as detecting users' malicious intentions or reporting emergency medical situations. By exploring these issues, the paper aims to emphasize the importance of ethical, legal, and policy considerations in BCI design and calls on experts in relevant fields to participate in the discussion together and formulate appropriate guidelines and policy frameworks.