Evaluation of computed tomography artefacts of carbon-fiber and titanium implants in patients with spinal oligometastatic disease undergoing stereotactic ablative radiotherapy

Zeger Rijs,Khandkar Ali Kawsar,Priyanshu Saha,Michiel van de Sande,Darren Lui
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-52498-2
IF: 4.6
2024-03-21
Scientific Reports
Abstract:This study evaluated artefacts on computed tomography (CT) images using Hounsfield units (HU) in patients with spinal oligometastatic disease who received carbon-fiber (CF; n = 11) or titanium (n = 11) spine implants and underwent stereotactic ablative radiotherapy (SABR). Pre- and postoperative HU were measured at the vertebral body, pedicle, and spinal cord at three different levels: the lower instrumented vertebra, the level of metastatic spinal cord compression, and an uninvolved level. Areas measured at each level were delicately matched pre- and postoperatively. Significant differences in HU were observed at the vertebral body, the pedicle, and the spinal cord at the lowest instrumented vertebra level for both CF and titanium (average increase 1.54-fold and 5.11-fold respectively). At the metastatic spinal cord compression level, a trend towards a higher HU-increase was observed in titanium compared with CF treated patients (average increase 2.51-fold and 1.43-fold respectively). The relatively high postoperative HU-increase after insertion of titanium implants indicated CT artefacts, while the relatively low HU-increase of CF implants was not associated with artefacts. Less CT artefacts could facilitate an easier contouring phase in radiotherapy planning. In addition, we propose a CT artefact grading system based on postoperative HU-increase. This system could serve as a valuable tool in future research to assess if less CT artefacts lead to time savings during radiotherapy treatment planning and, potentially, to better tumoricidal effects and less adverse effects if particle therapy would be administered.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the difference in artifacts on computed tomography (CT) images after the use of carbon fiber (CF) and titanium alloy implants in patients with spinal oligometastatic disease (OMD) treated with stereotactic ablative radiotherapy (SABR). Specifically, the study aims to: 1. **Quantify CT artifacts**: Compare the changes in artifacts on CT images before and after the use of carbon fiber and titanium alloy implants by measuring Hounsfield units (HU). 2. **Evaluate the impact of artifacts on radiotherapy planning**: Explore whether the artifacts produced by implants of different materials on CT images will affect the accuracy and effectiveness of radiotherapy. 3. **Propose a CT artifact grading system**: Based on the increase in HU after surgery, propose a CT artifact grading system to evaluate the severity of artifacts produced by different material implants. ### Research background - **Spinal oligometastatic disease (OMD)**: Approximately 70% of bone metastatic cancers are located in the spine. OMD refers to a limited (≤5) number of metastatic lesions in the spine, and these lesions can be treated by surgery and radiotherapy. - **Stereotactic ablative radiotherapy (SABR)**: It is a high - precision radiotherapy method that can accurately deliver a high - dose radiation to the tumor site while minimizing damage to surrounding normal tissues. - **Challenges of metal implants**: Commonly used titanium alloy implants can produce significant artifacts on CT images, affecting the planning and implementation of radiotherapy. Carbon fiber implants may reduce such artifacts. ### Research methods - **Patient selection**: Include 22 patients with spinal oligometastatic disease who received carbon fiber or titanium alloy implants. - **Data collection**: Use the standard CT protocol to measure the HU values of the vertebral body, pedicle, and spinal cord within the first week before and after surgery. - **Statistical analysis**: Use the paired t - test to compare the changes in HU values before and after surgery. ### Main findings - **Carbon fiber implants**: The HU value increased after surgery, but the increase was small (an average of 1.54 times), and it was mainly concentrated at the lowest implanted vertebral body level. - **Titanium alloy implants**: The HU value increased significantly after surgery (an average of 5.11 times), especially at the lowest implanted vertebral body level. - **CT artifact grading system**: According to the increase in HU after surgery, a CT artifact grading system from 0 to 5 was proposed, where 0 represents no artifact and 5 represents a severe artifact. ### Conclusions - **Advantages of carbon fiber implants**: Compared with titanium alloy implants, carbon fiber implants produce fewer artifacts on CT images, which is helpful for more accurate radiotherapy planning. - **Future applications**: The proposed CT artifact grading system can be used in future studies to evaluate whether reducing CT artifacts can save radiotherapy planning time, improve treatment effects, and reduce adverse reactions. Through these research results, the author hopes to provide clinicians with a method for evaluating and selecting implants, thereby optimizing the treatment effect of spinal oligometastatic disease.