Effects of road network structure on the performance of urban traffic systems

Chao-Yun Wu,Mao-Bin Hu,Rui Jiang,Qing-Yi Hao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physa.2020.125361
2021-02-01
Abstract:Urban traffic system is important for the convenience and efficiency of people’s daily life. The understanding of inter-relations between urban street network and traffic flow can help the planning process of urban systems. Based on cellular automata modeling, this paper studies the influence of aspect ratio of a rectangular urban network on the dynamics of traffic system. The performance of road network is examined with the Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (MFD). The maximal arrival rate and the critical density of congestion of MFD are investigated as two main indicators for system performance. Under the closed boundary condition, the square network shows the maximum arrival rate, but with a relatively lower critical density of congestion. With the increase of aspect ratio, the arrival rate decreases, while the critical congestion density increases. The phenomena can be explained by the vehicle distribution in the network, the left-turning and U-turning demand, and the average travel distance.
physics, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the impact of urban road network structures on the performance of traffic systems, especially how the aspect ratio of rectangular urban road networks affects the dynamic characteristics of traffic systems. Specifically, the article evaluates the impact of urban road networks with different aspect ratios on key indicators such as traffic flow, arrival rate, and critical congestion density by analyzing the Macroscopic Fundamental Diagram (MFD). ### Research Background and Problem Description 1. **Importance of Urban Traffic Systems** - Urban traffic systems are crucial for the convenience and efficiency of people's daily lives. - Understanding the inter - relationship between urban street networks and traffic flows is helpful in the urban planning process. 2. **Research Objectives** - To explore the impact of the aspect ratio of rectangular urban road networks on the dynamic characteristics of their traffic systems. - To evaluate, through MFD analysis, the maximum arrival rate and critical congestion density of networks with different aspect ratios, which are the two main criteria for measuring system performance. 3. **Specific Problems** - **Maximum Arrival Rate**: Under different aspect ratios, which network structure can achieve the highest vehicle arrival rate? - **Critical Congestion Density**: Under different aspect ratios, which network structure can withstand a higher vehicle density without serious congestion? ### Main Findings - **Square Network (Aspect Ratio of 1)**: It has the highest maximum arrival rate, but its critical congestion density is low, and it is prone to congestion at a relatively low vehicle density. - **High - Aspect - Ratio Network**: As the aspect ratio increases, the maximum arrival rate gradually decreases, but the critical congestion density increases, meaning that this network structure can maintain better traffic fluidity at a higher vehicle density. ### Reasons for Explaining the Phenomena - **Vehicle Distribution**: In square networks, there is a high demand for left - turns and U - turns, which leads to blockages in the main lanes easily and thus affects the performance of the entire network. - **Average Travel Distance**: In high - aspect - ratio networks, the average travel distance of vehicles is longer, but the demand for left - turns and U - turns is reduced, which reduces the possibility of local congestion and thus increases the overall critical congestion density. ### Conclusion This study reveals the profound impact of urban road network structures on the performance of traffic systems, especially the performance differences under different aspect ratios. These findings can provide valuable references for urban planners to help them optimize urban road designs to relieve traffic congestion and improve the overall performance of traffic systems.