Comparative Traffic Performance Analysis of Urban Transportation Network Structures

Behnam Amini,Farideddin Peiravian,Morteza Mojarradi,Sybil Derrible
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1507.03612
2015-07-14
Abstract:The network structure of an urban transportation system has a significant impact on its traffic performance. This study uses network indicators along with several traffic performance measures including speed, trip length, travel time, and traffic volume, to compare a selection of seven transportation networks with a variety of structures and under different travel demand conditions. The selected network structures are: modified linear, branch, grid, 3-directional grid, 1-ring web, 2-ring web, and radial. For the analysis, a base origin-destination matrix is chosen, to which different growth factors are applied in order to simulate various travel demand conditions. Results show that overall the 2-ring web network offers the most efficient traffic performance, followed by the grid and the 1-ring networks. A policy application of this study is that the branch, 3-directional grid, and radial networks are mostly suited for small cities with uncongested traffic conditions. In contrast, the 2-ring web, grid, and 1-ring web networks are better choices for large urban areas since they offer more connectivity, thus allowing them to perform efficiently under congested traffic conditions.
Physics and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the impact of urban traffic network structures on traffic performance. Specifically, by comparing the traffic performance indicators (including speed, trip length, travel time, traffic volume, capacity ratio (v/c), vehicle - driving distance (VDT)) of urban traffic networks with different structures (such as the modified linear network, branch network, grid network, three - way grid network, single - ring network, double - ring network and radial network) under different travel - demand conditions, the author evaluates the performance of these network structures under various traffic demands. The main purpose of the paper is to determine which network structure can provide more effective traffic performance under different traffic - demand conditions, so as to provide guidance for urban traffic planning and management. Through this research, the author hopes to understand whether the traffic performance of urban traffic networks can be improved by choosing appropriate network structures. Especially under high - traffic - demand conditions, which network structures can better handle traffic flow, reduce congestion and improve overall traffic efficiency. This research has important practical significance for urban planners and traffic managers, and can help them make more scientific and reasonable decisions when designing and optimizing urban traffic systems.