Combining Approximation Algorithms for the Prize-Collecting TSP

Michel X. Goemans

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0910.0553

2009-10-03

Data Structures and Algorithms

Abstract:We present a 1.91457-approximation algorithm for the prize-collecting travelling salesman problem. This is obtained by combining a randomized variant of a rounding algorithm of Bienstock et al. and a primal-dual algorithm of Goemans and Williamson.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

An improved approximation guarantee for Prize-Collecting TSP

Jannis Blauth,Martin Nägele

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2212.03776

2023-04-12

Abstract:We present a new approximation algorithm for the (metric) prize-collecting traveling salesperson problem (PCTSP). In PCTSP, opposed to the classical traveling salesperson problem (TSP), one may not include a vertex of the input graph in the returned tour at the cost of a given vertex-dependent penalty, and the objective is to balance the length of the tour and the incurred penalties for omitted vertices by minimizing the sum of the two. We present an algorithm that achieves an approximation guarantee of $1.774$ with respect to the natural linear programming relaxation of the problem. This significantly reduces the gap between the approximability of classical TSP and PCTSP, beating the previously best known approximation factor of $1.915$. As a key ingredient of our improvement, we present a refined decomposition technique for solutions of the LP relaxation, and show how to leverage components of that decomposition as building blocks for our tours.

Data Structures and Algorithms,Discrete Mathematics
Approximating Prize-Collecting Variants of TSP

Morteza Alimi,Tobias Mömke,Michael Ruderer

2024-11-22

Abstract:We present an approximation algorithm for the Prize-collecting Ordered Traveling Salesman Problem (PCOTSP), which simultaneously generalizes the Prize-collecting TSP and the Ordered TSP. The Prize-collecting TSP is well-studied and has a long history, with the current best approximation factor slightly below $1.6$, shown by Blauth, Klein and Nägele [IPCO 2024]. The best approximation ratio for Ordered TSP is $\frac{3}{2}+\frac{1}{e}$, presented by Böhm, Friggstad, Mömke, Spoerhase [SODA 2025] and Armbruster, Mnich, Nägele [Approx 2024]. The former also present a factor 2.2131 approximation algorithm for Multi-Path-TSP. By carefully tuning the techniques of the latest results on the aforementioned problems and leveraging the unique properties of our problem, we present a 2.097-approximation algorithm for PCOTSP. A key idea in our result is to first sample a set of trees, and then probabilistically pick up some vertices, while using the pruning ideas of Blauth, Klein, Nägele [IPCO 2024] on other vertices to get cheaper parity correction; the sampling probability and the penalty paid by the LP playing a crucial part in both cases. A straightforward adaptation of the aforementioned pruning ideas would only give minuscule improvements over standard parity correction methods. Instead, we use the specific characteristics of our problem together with properties gained from running a simple combinatorial algorithm to bring the approximation factor below 2.1. Our techniques extend to Prize-collecting Multi-Path TSP, building on results from Böhm, Friggstad, Mömke, Spoerhase [SODA 2025], leading to a 2.41-approximation.

Data Structures and Algorithms
Scheduling on a Graph with Release Times

Yu Wei,Golin Mordecai,Zhang Guochuan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10951-021-00680-z

2021-01-01

Journal of Scheduling

Abstract:We study a generalization of the well-known traveling salesman problem in a metric space, in which each city is associated with a release time. The salesman has to visit each city at or after its release time. There exists a naive 5/2-approximation algorithm where the salesman simply starts to route the network after all cities are released. Interestingly, this bound has never been improved for more than two decades. In this paper, we revisit the problem and achieve the following results. First, we devise an approximation algorithm with performance ratio less than 5/2 when the number of distinct release times is fixed. Then, we analyze a natural class of algorithms and show that no performance ratio better than 5/2 is possible unless the Metric TSP can be approximated with a ratio strictly less than 3/2, which is a well-known longstanding open question. Finally, we consider a special case where the graph has a heavy edge and present an approximation algorithm with performance ratio less than 5/2.
A $(\frac32+\frac1{\mathrm{e}})$-Approximation Algorithm for Ordered TSP

Susanne Armbruster,Matthias Mnich,Martin Nägele

2024-05-10

Abstract:We present a new $(\frac32+\frac1{\mathrm{e}})$-approximation algorithm for the Ordered Traveling Salesperson Problem (Ordered TSP). Ordered TSP is a variant of the classical metric Traveling Salesperson Problem (TSP) where a specified subset of vertices needs to appear on the output Hamiltonian cycle in a given order, and the task is to compute a cheapest such cycle. Our approximation guarantee of approximately $1.868$ holds with respect to the value of a natural new linear programming (LP) relaxation for Ordered TSP. Our result significantly improves upon the previously best known guarantee of $\frac52$ for this problem and thereby considerably reduces the gap between approximability of Ordered TSP and metric TSP. Our algorithm is based on a decomposition of the LP solution into weighted trees that serve as building blocks in our tour construction.

Data Structures and Algorithms
An Improved Approximation Algorithm for TSP in the Half Integral Case

Anna Karlin,Nathan Klein,Shayan Oveis Gharan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1908.00227

2019-08-01

Abstract:We design a $1.49993$-approximation algorithm for the metric traveling salesperson problem (TSP) for instances in which an optimal solution to the subtour linear programming relaxation is half-integral. These instances received significant attention over the last decade due to a conjecture of Schalekamp, Williamson and van Zuylen stating that half-integral LP solutions have the largest integrality gap over all fractional solutions. So, if the conjecture of Schalekamp et al. holds true, our result shows that the integrality gap of the subtour polytope is bounded away from $3/2$.

Data Structures and Algorithms,Discrete Mathematics,Probability
FIXED RATIO POLYNOMIAL TIME APPROXIMATION ALGORITHM FOR THE PRIZE-COLLECTING ASYMMETRIC TRAVELING SALESMAN PROBLEM

Ksenia Rizhenko,Katherine Neznakhina,Michael Khachay

DOI: https://doi.org/10.15826/umj.2023.1.012

2023-07-27

Ural mathematical journal

Abstract:We develop the first fixed-ratio approximation algorithm for the well-known Prize-Collecting Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem, which has numerous valuable applications in operations research. An instance of this problem is given by a complete node- and edge-weighted digraph $G$. Each node of the graph $G$ can either be visited by the resulting route or skipped, for some penalty, while the arcs of $G$ are weighted by non-negative transportation costs that fulfill the triangle inequality constraint. The goal is to find a closed walk that minimizes the total transportation costs augmented by the accumulated penalties. We show that an arbitrary $\alpha$-approximation algorithm for the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem induces an $(\alpha+1)$-approximation for the problem in question. In particular, using the recent $(22+\varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm of V. Traub and J. Vygen that improves the seminal result of O. Svensson, J. Tarnavski, and L. Végh, we obtain $(23+\varepsilon)$-approximate solutions for the problem.
Asymptotically Optimal Algorithms for the Prize-Collecting Traveling Salesman Problem on Random Inputs

Edward Kh. Gimadi,Oxana Tsidulko

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-38629-0_16

2020-01-01

Abstract:AbstractThe Prize-Collecting Traveling Salesman Problem is a class of generalizations of the classic Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) where it is not necessary to visit all the vertices. Given the edge costs and a certain profit associated with each vertex, the goal is to find a route which satisfies maximum collected profit and minimum traveling costs constraints. We show polynomial-time approximation algorithms for two variants of the problem and establish conditions under which the presented algorithms are asymptotically optimal on random inputs.
Improved approximation algorithms for routing shop scheduling

Wei Yu,Guochuan Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-25591-5_5

2011-01-01

Abstract:We investigate a generalization of classical shop scheduling where n jobs are located at the vertices of a general undirected graph and m machines must travel between the vertices to process the jobs. The aim is to minimize the makespan. For the open shop problem, we develop an O(logmloglogm)-approximation algorithm that significantly improves upon the best known $O(\sqrt{m})$-approximation algorithm. For the flow shop problem, we present an O(m2/3)-approximation algorithm that improves upon the best known $\max\{\frac{m+1}{2},\rho\}$-approximation algorithm, where ρ is the approximation factor for metric TSP.
A $4/5$ - Approximation Algorithm for the Maximum Traveling Salesman Problem

Szymon Dudycz,Jan Marcinkowski,Katarzyna Paluch,Bartosz Rybicki

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1512.09236

2016-03-21

Abstract:In the maximum traveling salesman problem (Max TSP) we are given a complete undirected graph with nonnegative weights on the edges and we wish to compute a traveling salesman tour of maximum weight. We present a fast combinatorial $\frac 45$ - approximation algorithm for Max TSP. The previous best approximation for this problem was $\frac 79$. The new algorithm is based on a novel technique of eliminating difficult subgraphs via half-edges, a new method of edge coloring and a technique of exchanging edges. A half-edge of edge $e=(u,v)$ is informally speaking "a half of $e$ containing either $u$ or $v$".

Data Structures and Algorithms,Discrete Mathematics
13/9-approximation for Graphic TSP

Marcin Mucha

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1108.1130

2011-10-05

Abstract:The Travelling Salesman Problem is one the most fundamental and most studied problems in approximation algorithms. For more than 30 years, the best algorithm known for general metrics has been Christofides's algorithm with approximation factor of 3/2, even though the so-called Held-Karp LP relaxation of the problem is conjectured to have the integrality gap of only 4/3. Very recently, significant progress has been made for the important special case of graphic metrics, first by Oveis Gharan et al., and then by Momke and Svensson. In this paper, we provide an improved analysis for the approach introduced by Momke and Svensson yielding a bound of 13/9 on the approximation factor, as well as a bound of 19/12+epsilon for any epsilon>0 for a more general Travelling Salesman Path Problem in graphic metrics.

Data Structures and Algorithms
Practical Algorithms with Guaranteed Approximation Ratio for TTP with Maximum Tour Length Two

Jingyang Zhao,Mingyu Xiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2212.12240

2022-12-23

Abstract:The Traveling Tournament Problem (TTP) is a hard but interesting sports scheduling problem inspired by Major League Baseball, which is to design a double round-robin schedule such that each pair of teams plays one game in each other's home venue, minimizing the total distance traveled by all $n$ teams ($n$ is even). In this paper, we consider TTP-2, i.e., TTP under the constraint that at most two consecutive home games or away games are allowed for each team. We propose practical algorithms for TTP-2 with improved approximation ratios. Due to the different structural properties of the problem, all known algorithms for TTP-2 are different for $n/2$ being odd and even, and our algorithms are also different for these two cases. For even $n/2$, our approximation ratio is $1+3/n$, improving the previous result of $1+4/n$. For odd $n/2$, our approximation ratio is $1+5/n$, improving the previous result of $3/2+6/n$. In practice, our algorithms are easy to implement. Experiments on well-known benchmark sets show that our algorithms beat previously known solutions for all instances with an average improvement of $5.66\%$.

Data Structures and Algorithms
Improved FPT Approximation for Non-metric TSP

Evripidis Bampis,Bruno Escoffier,Michalis Xefteris

2024-07-11

Abstract:In the Traveling Salesperson Problem (TSP) we are given a list of locations and the distances between each pair of them. The goal is to find the shortest possible tour that visits each location exactly once and returns to the starting location. Inspired by the fact that general TSP cannot be approximated in polynomial time within any constant factor, while metric TSP admits a (slightly better than) $1.5$-approximation in polynomial time, Zhou, Li and Guo [Zhou et al., ISAAC '22] introduced a parameter that measures the distance of a given TSP instance from the metric case. They gave an FPT $3$-approximation algorithm parameterized by $k$, where $k$ is the number of triangles in which the edge costs violate the triangle inequality. In this paper, we design a $2.5$-approximation algorithm that runs in FPT time, improving the result of [Zhou et al., ISAAC '22].

Data Structures and Algorithms
On approximating a new generalization of traveling salesman problem

Zhengxin Huang,Xuanzhi Liao,Parvaiz Ahmad Naik,Xiaoye Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e31297

IF: 3.776

2024-05-17

Heliyon

Abstract:The current best-known performance guarantees for the extensively studied Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) of determinate approximation algorithms is 32, achieved by Christofides' algorithm 47 years ago. This paper investigates a new generalization problem of the TSP, termed the Minimum-Cost Bounded Degree Connected Subgraph (MBDCS) problem. In the MBDCS problem, the goal is to identify a minimum-cost connected subgraph containing n=|V| edges from an input graph G=(V,E) with degree upper bounds for particular vertices. We show that for certain special cases of MBDCS, the aim is equivalent to finding a minimum-cost Hamiltonian cycle for the input graph, same as the TSP. To appropriately solve MBDCS, we initially present an integer programming formulation for the problem. Subsequently, we propose an algorithm to approximate the optimal solution by applying the iterative rounding technique to solution of the integer programming relaxation. We demonstrate that the returned subgraph of our proposed algorithm is one of the best guarantees for the MBDCS problem in polynomial time, assuming P≠NP. This study views the optimization of TSP as finding a minimum-cost connected subgraph containing n edges with degree upper bounds for certain vertices, and it may provide new insights into optimizing the TSP in future research.
An LP-based 3/2-approximation algorithm for the graphic s-t path TSP

Zhihan Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1304.7055

2013-04-26

Data Structures and Algorithms

Abstract:We design a new LP-based algorithm for the graphic $s$-$t$ path Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP), which achieves the best approximation factor of 1.5. The algorithm is based on the idea of narrow cuts due to An, Kleinberg, and Shmoys. It partly answers an open question of Seb\H{o}.
Approximation Algorithms for Generalized MST and TSP in Grid Clusters

Binay Bhattacharya,Ante Ćustić,Akbar Rafiey,Arash Rafiey,Vladyslav Sokol

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1507.04438

2015-07-16

Abstract:We consider a special case of the generalized minimum spanning tree problem (GMST) and the generalized travelling salesman problem (GTSP) where we are given a set of points inside the integer grid (in Euclidean plane) where each grid cell is $1 \times 1$. In the MST version of the problem, the goal is to find a minimum tree that contains exactly one point from each non-empty grid cell (cluster). Similarly, in the TSP version of the problem, the goal is to find a minimum weight cycle containing one point from each non-empty grid cell. We give a $(1+4\sqrt{2}+\epsilon)$ and $(1.5+8\sqrt{2}+\epsilon)$-approximation algorithm for these two problems in the described setting, respectively. Our motivation is based on the problem posed in [7] for a constant approximation algorithm. The authors designed a PTAS for the more special case of the GMST where non-empty cells are connected end dense enough. However, their algorithm heavily relies on this connectivity restriction and is unpractical. Our results develop the topic further.

Discrete Mathematics,Computational Geometry,Data Structures and Algorithms
An Empirical Analysis of Approximation Algorithms for the Euclidean Traveling Salesman Problem

Yihui He,Ming Xiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1705.09058

2017-05-25

Abstract:With applications to many disciplines, the traveling salesman problem (TSP) is a classical computer science optimization problem with applications to industrial engineering, theoretical computer science, bioinformatics, and several other disciplines. In recent years, there have been a plethora of novel approaches for approximate solutions ranging from simplistic greedy to cooperative distributed algorithms derived from artificial intelligence. In this paper, we perform an evaluation and analysis of cornerstone algorithms for the Euclidean TSP. We evaluate greedy, 2-opt, and genetic algorithms. We use several datasets as input for the algorithms including a small dataset, a mediumsized dataset representing cities in the United States, and a synthetic dataset consisting of 200 cities to test algorithm scalability. We discover that the greedy and 2-opt algorithms efficiently calculate solutions for smaller datasets. Genetic algorithm has the best performance for optimality for medium to large datasets, but generally have longer runtime. Our implementations is public available.

Artificial Intelligence
Improved guarantees for the a priori TSP

Jannis Blauth,Meike Neuwohner,Luise Puhlmann,Jens Vygen

2023-09-19

Abstract:We revisit the a priori TSP (with independent activation) and prove stronger approximation guarantees than were previously known. In the a priori TSP, we are given a metric space $(V,c)$ and an activation probability $p(v)$ for each customer $v\in V$. We ask for a TSP tour $T$ for $V$ that minimizes the expected length after cutting $T$ short by skipping the inactive customers. All known approximation algorithms select a nonempty subset $S$ of the customers and construct a master route solution, consisting of a TSP tour for $S$ and two edges connecting every customer $v\in V\setminus S$ to a nearest customer in $S$. We address the following questions. If we randomly sample the subset $S$, what should be the sampling probabilities? How much worse than the optimum can the best master route solution be? The answers to these questions (we provide almost matching lower and upper bounds) lead to improved approximation guarantees: less than 3.1 with randomized sampling, and less than 5.9 with a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm.

Data Structures and Algorithms,Discrete Mathematics
Approximation of the Double Travelling Salesman Problem with Multiple Stacks

Laurent Alfandari,Sophie Toulouse

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2010.00138

2020-10-01

Abstract:The Double Travelling Salesman Problem with Multiple Stacks, DTSPMS, deals with the collect and delivery of n commodities in two distinct cities, where the pickup and the delivery tours are related by LIFO constraints. During the pickup tour, commodities are loaded into a container of k rows, or stacks, with capacity c. This paper focuses on computational aspects of the DTSPMS, which is NP-hard. We first review the complexity of two critical subproblems: deciding whether a given pair of pickup and delivery tours is feasible and, given a loading plan, finding an optimal pair of pickup and delivery tours, are both polynomial under some conditions on k and c. We then prove a (3k)/2 standard approximation for the MinMetrickDTSPMS, where k is a universal constant, and other approximation results for various versions of the problem. We finally present a matching-based heuristic for the 2DTSPMS, which is a special case with k=2 rows, when the distances are symmetric. This yields a 1/2-o(1), 3/4-o(1) and 3/2+o(1) standard approximation for respectively Max2DTSPMS, its restriction Max2DTSPMS-(1,2) with distances 1 and 2, and Min2DTSPMS-(1,2), and a 1/2-o(1) differential approximation for Min2DTSPMS and Max2DTSPMS.

Discrete Mathematics,Computational Complexity
Improved Inapproximability for TSP

Michael Lampis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1206.2497

2012-06-12

Abstract:The Traveling Salesman Problem is one of the most studied problems in computational complexity and its approximability has been a long standing open question. Currently, the best known inapproximability threshold known is 220/219 due to Papadimitriou and Vempala. Here, using an essentially different construction and also relying on the work of Berman and Karpinski on bounded occurrence CSPs, we give an alternative and simpler inapproximability proof which improves the bound to 185/184.

Computational Complexity
A Randomized Rounding Algorithm for the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem

Michel X. Goemans,Nicholas J. A. Harvey,Kamal Jain,Mohit Singh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0909.0941

2009-09-05

Abstract:We present an algorithm for the asymmetric traveling salesman problem on instances which satisfy the triangle inequality. Like several existing algorithms, it achieves approximation ratio O(log n). Unlike previous algorithms, it uses randomized rounding.

Data Structures and Algorithms

Combining Approximation Algorithms for the Prize-Collecting TSP

An improved approximation guarantee for Prize-Collecting TSP

Approximating Prize-Collecting Variants of TSP

Scheduling on a Graph with Release Times

A $(\frac32+\frac1{\mathrm{e}})$-Approximation Algorithm for Ordered TSP

An Improved Approximation Algorithm for TSP in the Half Integral Case

FIXED RATIO POLYNOMIAL TIME APPROXIMATION ALGORITHM FOR THE PRIZE-COLLECTING ASYMMETRIC TRAVELING SALESMAN PROBLEM

Asymptotically Optimal Algorithms for the Prize-Collecting Traveling Salesman Problem on Random Inputs

Improved approximation algorithms for routing shop scheduling

A $4/5$ - Approximation Algorithm for the Maximum Traveling Salesman Problem

13/9-approximation for Graphic TSP

Practical Algorithms with Guaranteed Approximation Ratio for TTP with Maximum Tour Length Two

Improved FPT Approximation for Non-metric TSP

On approximating a new generalization of traveling salesman problem

An LP-based 3/2-approximation algorithm for the graphic s-t path TSP

Approximation Algorithms for Generalized MST and TSP in Grid Clusters

An Empirical Analysis of Approximation Algorithms for the Euclidean Traveling Salesman Problem

Improved guarantees for the a priori TSP

Approximation of the Double Travelling Salesman Problem with Multiple Stacks

Improved Inapproximability for TSP

A Randomized Rounding Algorithm for the Asymmetric Traveling Salesman Problem