Abstract:Safety learning generates associative links between neutral stimuli and the absence of threat, promoting the inhibition of fear and security-seeking behaviors. Precisely how safety learning is mediated at the level of underlying brain systems, particularly in humans, remains unclear. Here, we integrated a novel Pavlovian conditioned inhibition task with ultra-high field (7 Tesla) fMRI to examine the neural basis of safety learning in 49 healthy participants. In our task, participants were conditioned to two safety signals: a conditioned inhibitor that predicted threat omission when paired with a known threat signal (A+/AX-), and a standard safety signal that generally predicted threat omission (BC-). Both safety signals evoked equivalent autonomic and subjective learning responses but diverged strongly in terms of underlying brain activation (PFDR whole-brain corrected). The conditioned inhibitor was characterized by more prominent activation of the dorsal striatum, anterior insular, and dorsolateral PFC compared with the standard safety signal, whereas the latter evoked greater activation of the ventromedial PFC, posterior cingulate, and hippocampus, among other regions. Further analyses of the conditioned inhibitor indicated that its initial learning was characterized by consistent engagement of dorsal striatal, midbrain, thalamic, premotor, and prefrontal subregions. These findings suggest that safety learning via conditioned inhibition involves a distributed cortico-striatal circuitry, separable from broader cortical regions involved with processing standard safety signals (e.g., CS-). This cortico-striatal system could represent a novel neural substrate of safety learning, underlying the initial generation of "stimulus-safety" associations, distinct from wider cortical correlates of safety processing, which facilitate the behavioral outcomes of learning.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Identifying safety is critical for maintaining adaptive levels of anxiety, but the neural mechanisms of human safety learning remain unclear. Using 7 Tesla fMRI, we compared learning-related brain activity for a conditioned inhibitor, which actively predicted threat omission, and a standard safety signal (CS-), which was passively unpaired with threat. The inhibitor engaged an extended circuitry primarily featuring the dorsal striatum, along with thalamic, midbrain, and premotor/PFC regions. The CS- exclusively involved cortical safety-related regions observed in basic safety conditioning, such as the vmPFC. These findings extend current models to include learning-specific mechanisms for encoding stimulus-safety associations, which might be distinguished from expression-related cortical mechanisms. These insights may suggest novel avenues for targeting dysfunctional safety learning in psychopathology.

Observational threat learning influences costly avoidance behaviour in healthy humans

Higher threat avoidance costs reduce avoidance behaviour which in turn promotes fear extinction in humans

Social threat avoidance depends on action-outcome predictability

Observational learning of threat-related attentional bias

Electrocortical responses in anticipation of avoidable and inevitable threats: a multisite study

Social threat learning transfers to decision making in humans

Threat impairs flexible use of a cognitive map

Persistent defensive reactivity during extensive avoidance training as a potential mechanism for the perpetuation of safety behaviors

How Distributed Subcortical Integration of Reward and Threat May Inform Subsequent Approach-Avoidance Decisions

How distributed subcortical integration of reward and threat may inform approach-avoidance decisions

The influence of postural threat-induced anxiety on locomotor learning and updating

Devaluation of response-produced safety signals reveals circuits for goal-directed versus habitual avoidance in dorsal striatum

The fear-avoidance model as an embodied prediction of threat

Oscillatory correlates of threat imminence during virtual navigation

Not so bad: avoidance and aversive discounting modulate threat appraisal in anterior cingulate and medial prefrontal cortex

Indoor or Outdoor? Generalization of Costly Pain-Related Avoidance Behavior to Conceptually Related Contexts

Can I see it in the eyes? An investigation of freezing‐like motion patterns in response to avoidable threat

Between Scylla and Charybdis: Fixed-ratio avoidance response effort and unavoidable shock extinction in humans

Impact of Observational and Direct Learning on Fear Conditioning and Generalization in Humans

Cortico-Striatal Activity Characterizes Human Safety Learning via Pavlovian Conditioned Inhibition

The fine line between 'brave' and 'reckless': amygdala reactivity and regulation predict recognition of risk