Abstract:BackgroundWearable sensor systems can provide data for at-home gait analyses and input to controllers for rehabilitation devices but they often have reduced estimation accuracy compared to laboratory systems. The goal of this study is to evaluate a portable, low-cost system for measuring ground reaction forces and ankle joint torques in treadmill walking and calf raises.MethodsTo estimate the ground reaction forces and ankle joint torques, we developed a custom instrumented insole and a tissue force sensor. Six healthy subjects completed a collection of movements (calf raises, 1.0 m/s walking, and 1.5 m/s walking) on two separate days. We trained artificial neural networks on the study data and compared the estimates to a multi-camera motion system and an instrumented treadmill. We evaluated the relative strength of each sensor by testing each sensor’s ability to predict the ankle joint torque calculated from a reference inverse kinematics algorithm. We assessed model accuracy through root mean squared error and normalized root mean square error. We hypothesized that the estimation of the models would have normalized root mean square error measures less than 10 %.ResultsFor walking at 1.0 and walking at 1.5 m/s, the single-task, intra-day and multi-task, intra-day predictions had normalized root mean square error less than 10 % for all three force components and both center of pressure components. For the calf raise task, the single-task, intra-day and multi-task, intra-day predictions had normalized root mean square error less than 10 % for only the anterior-posterior center of pressure. The multi-task, intra-day model had similar predictions to the single-task, intra-day model. The normalized root mean square error of predictions from the insole sensor alone were less than 10 % for walking at 1.0 m/s and 1.5 m/s. No sensor was sufficient for the calf raise task. The combination of the insole sensor and the tendon sensor had lower normalized root mean square error than the individual sensors for all three tasks.ConclusionsThe proposed sensor system provided accurate estimates for five of the six components of the ground reaction kinetics during walking at 1.0 and 1.5 m/s and one of the six components during the calf raise task. The normalized root mean square error of the predictions of the ground reaction forces were similar to published studies using commercial devices. The proposed system of low-cost sensors can provide useful estimations of ankle joint torque for both walking and calf raises for future studies in mobile gait analysis.

AHRS-Assisted Dynamic Response Compensation of VGRF for Capacitive Force-Sensing Insoles

A Systematic Approach to the Design and Characterization of a Smart Insole for Detecting Vertical Ground Reaction Force (vGRF) in Gait Analysis

Calibrating Low-Cost Smart Insole Sensors with Recurrent Neural Networks for Accurate Prediction of Center of Pressure

Design of an Artificial Neural Network Algorithm for a Low-Cost Insole Sensor to Estimate the Ground Reaction Force (GRF) and Calibrate the Center of Pressure (CoP)

Soft insoles for estimating 3D ground reaction forces using 3D printed foam-like sensors

Design of a low-cost force insoles to estimate ground reaction forces during human gait

Consumer-priced wearable sensors combined with deep learning can be used to accurately predict ground reaction forces during various treadmill running conditions

Predicting vertical and shear ground reaction forces during walking and jogging using wearable plantar pressure insoles

VRInsole: an Unobtrusive and Immersive Mobility Training System for Stroke Rehabilitation

Comparison of the Accuracy of Ground Reaction Force Component Estimation between Supervised Machine Learning and Deep Learning Methods Using Pressure Insoles

Optimal estimation of total plantar force for monitoring gait in daily life activities with low-price insole system

Estimation of ground reaction forces and ankle moment with multiple, low-cost sensors

Wireless pressure insoles for measuring ground reaction forces and trajectories of the centre of pressure during functional activities

Pressure-Sensitive Insoles for Real-Time Gait-Related Applications

Estimating ground reaction force with novel carbon nanotube-based textile insole pressure sensors

Wireless Multi-Axial Force Sensing Shoe for Gait Abnormalities Monitoring

Deep learning approach to estimate foot pressure distribution in walking with application for a cost-effective insole system

Smart Insoles for Gait Analysis Based on Meshless Conductive Rubber Sensors and Neural Networks

Carbon Fiber‐Based Smart Plantar Pressure Mapping Insole System for Remote Gait Analysis and Motion Identification

Kinematic Analysis of Human Gait Based on Wearable Sensor System for Gait Rehabilitation

Feed forward artificial neural network to predict contact force at medial knee joint: Application to gait modification