Development of a Load Model Validation Framework Applied to Synthetic Turbulent Wind Field Evaluation

Paul J. Meyer,Matthias L. Huhn,Julia Gottschall

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en17040797

IF: 3.2

2024-02-07

Energies

Abstract:The validation of aeroelastic load models used for load calculations on wind turbines substantially increases the confidence in the accuracy and correctness of these models. In this contribution, we introduce a framework for the validation of these models, integrating a normalized area metric as an objective, quantifiable validation metric that considers the entire statistical distribution of a model and a benchmark and additionally enables a comparison of model accuracy between sensors of different physical units. The framework is applied to test cases that evaluate varying synthetic turbulent wind fields. Two test cases with a focus on turbulence parameters and abnormal shear conditions based on comprehensive wind measurements at the Testfeld Bremerhaven are used to demonstrate the workflow with four different members using IEC-compliant and measurement-derived wind field parameters, respectively. Along with these measurements, an uncertainty model for synthetic wind fields is introduced to quantify propagated wind measurement uncertainties associated with the measured boundary conditions during a validation campaign. The framework is presented as a straightforward and concise methodology to not only find but also quantify mismatches of load models. Major mismatches are found for wind fields associated with larger uncertainties in the mean wind field due to a reduced spatial resolution of measurements.

energy & fuels

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Aims to Solve

This paper aims to address several key issues in the validation of aeroelastic load models for wind turbines and proposes a new validation framework to assess the impact of different synthetic turbulent wind fields on load simulation results.

#### Main Objectives:
1. **Develop a Load Model Validation Framework**: Introduce a new validation framework, including a normalized area metric, for objective and quantitative validation of aeroelastic load models for wind turbines.
2. **Evaluate Different Synthetic Turbulent Wind Fields**: Use this framework to evaluate synthetic turbulent wind fields based on different turbulence models and wind field parameters to determine which model and parameters are most suitable for load model validation.
3. **Introduce an Uncertainty Model**: Propose an uncertainty model to quantify measurement uncertainties in synthetic wind fields and their propagation effects in the validation process.

#### Specific Research Content:
- **Design of the Validation Framework**: The framework uses a normalized area metric to compare the differences between simulation results and benchmark data.
- **Generation of Synthetic Wind Fields**: Detailed methods for generating synthetic wind fields based on different turbulence models (such as the Kaimal and Mann models) are described.
- **Uncertainty Analysis**: Consideration of random seeds and parameter uncertainties in synthetic wind fields to evaluate their impact on simulation results.

Through these methods, the paper aims to enhance the confidence in aeroelastic load models and provide a reliable validation tool for future research.