Administering a Chill Pill? Better Regulation and the Potential for Regulatory Chill in European Union Health Policy

Eleanor Brooks,Kathrin Lauber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1215/03616878-11257072

2024-04-03

Abstract:Abstract The European Union's ‘good governance’ programme, known as Better Regulation, seeks to improve the quality of EU legislation by controlling the policy-making process. Despite its importance, it is rarely accounted for in the EU health policy literature. Seeking to address this gap, this article introduces Better Regulation in the context of health policy-making. We conceptualise a model of regulatory chill, drawn from the literature on international trade, to interrogate the impact of Better Regulation on EU policy-making processes. Using examples from the literature and data from a series of interviews with EU officials, we explore potential pathways of response and anticipatory chill, identifying direct enforcement of Better Regulation, its utilisation by corporate actors, interpretation of its provision by officials, and feedback loops as possible routes of influence. We argue that such an approach presents methodological challenges, but also offers a valuable way of conceptualising the relevance of political institutions in general, and Better Regulation specifically, for health. As part of broader calls for attention to the political determinants of health, our findings highlight the particular, and often overlooked, importance of meta-regulatory policy frameworks.

social sciences, biomedical,health care sciences & services,health policy & services,social issues