Effects of Battery Energy Storage Systems on the Frequency Stability of Weak Grids with a High-Share of Grid-Connected Converters

Pedro Paiva,Rui Castro
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics13061083
IF: 2.9
2024-03-15
Electronics
Abstract:To achieve an energy sector independent from fossil fuels, a significant increase in the penetration of variable renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind power, is imperative. However, these sources lack the inertia provided by conventional thermo-electric power stations, which is essential for maintaining grid frequency stability. In this study, a grid resembling Madeira Island's power generation mix was modeled using the Matlab/Simulink platform. The model included solar, wind, hydro, and thermo-electric generation to accurately represent the energy landscape of Madeira Island. Three scenarios were examined: one reflecting the current power generation on Madeira Island, a future scenario with a substantial rise in the percentage of photovoltaic (PV) generation, and the same future scenario but incorporating a battery energy storage system (BESS). Various analyses were conducted to assess the impact on frequency stability during a ground fault and rapid load/generation changes. In the future scenario without a BESS, the thermoelectric power plant generator desynchronized, leading to system collapse in several simulations. However, with the addition of a BESS, a significant improvement in frequency stability was observed. The thermoelectric power plant generator could return to a steady state after each disturbance. Furthermore, both the maximum frequency deviation and the absolute value of the Rate of Change of Frequency (ROCOF) were reduced, indicating enhanced system performance and stability.
engineering, electrical & electronic,computer science, information systems,physics, applied
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to improve the frequency stability of a weak grid through the Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) in the case of a high proportion of renewable energy connected to the grid. Specifically, the paper focuses on the problem of the decline in grid frequency stability in weak grids that use a large amount of variable Renewable Energy Sources (vRES) such as photovoltaic (PV) and wind energy, because these energy sources lack the inertia provided by traditional thermal power plants. Through simulation, the paper studies the grid's response to frequency stability under different scenarios, namely the current scenario, the future scenario with high vRES penetration, and the future scenario with the addition of BESS, especially when the grid encounters rapid load changes, power generation losses or ground faults. ### Core problems of the paper 1. **Impact of high vRES penetration on frequency stability**: With the increase of renewable energy such as solar and wind energy, the uncontrollability and intermittency of these power sources pose a challenge to the frequency stability of the grid. Traditional thermal power plants provide inertia through rotating machinery, which helps maintain the stability of the grid frequency, while renewable energy is connected to the grid through power electronic converters and cannot provide this inertia. 2. **Role of BESS in improving frequency stability**: The paper explores the potential of the Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) in improving the frequency stability of weak grids with high vRES penetration. By introducing BESS in the future scenario with high vRES penetration, it studies the improvement effect on frequency stability. ### Research methods - **Modeling and simulation**: The paper uses the Matlab/Simulink platform to build a model similar to the Madeira Island power system, including solar, wind, hydro and thermoelectric power generation. Three scenarios are studied: - **Current scenario**: The vRES penetration is approximately 36%. - **Future scenario**: The vRES penetration increases to approximately 57%. - **Future scenario (including BESS)**: A 15 MW/10 MWh BESS is added on the basis of high vRES penetration. - **Disturbance analysis**: Under steady - state conditions, the following disturbances are applied to the system: - Step increase/decrease in load - Loss of solar power generation - Ground fault ### Main conclusions - **Frequency stability assessment**: By analyzing the maximum/minimum frequency deviation, Rate of Change of Frequency (ROCOF) and the time required to restore the steady state, the paper finds that: - In the future scenario with high vRES penetration without BESS, the thermoelectric generator loses synchronization, leading to system collapse. - After adding BESS, the frequency stability is significantly improved, and the thermoelectric generator can return to the steady state after each disturbance. - The absolute values of the maximum frequency deviation and ROCOF are both reduced, indicating that the system performance and stability are enhanced. ### Contributions of the paper - **Simplified and credible model**: It provides a simplified but credible representation of the Madeira Island power system, allowing for frequency stability studies. - **Positive impact of BESS**: It shows the positive role of BESS in improving frequency stability in the scenario of high vRES penetration. Through these studies, the paper provides important references and solutions for solving the frequency stability problem of weak grids with high vRES penetration.